Comparison in
Period 2
Master the AP skill of historical comparison across European colonial societies in North America, 1607 to 1754.
What Is Historical Comparison?
Historical comparison is the skill of identifying similarities and differences between two or more historical developments, events, or societies. On the AP exam, you must go beyond listing facts: you need to explain why those similarities or differences existed and what their significance was.
Why Period 2 Matters
Period 2 (1607-1754) saw multiple European powers establish colonies with vastly different goals, labor systems, and relationships with Indigenous peoples. This era is a natural testing ground for comparison because the same continent produced dramatically different colonial societies.
Three Empires, One Continent
The AP Comparison Framework
The College Board tests comparison through a specific structure. Every strong comparison must include three elements:
Similarity vs. Difference
Students often default to listing differences. But the strongest AP essays also identify unexpected similarities across colonial societies. Both approaches require evidence and explanation.
Categories for Comparison
When comparing colonial societies in Period 2, organize your analysis around these categories. Each provides a lens for identifying meaningful similarities and differences.
How to Write a Comparison
Example: Chesapeake vs. New England
Example: English vs. Spanish Labor
Both colonial powers used coerced labor, but the systems looked different. Let's walk through a full comparison.
Example: French vs. English Native Relations
Timeline of English Colonial Regions
Comparing Social Hierarchies
Each colonial power created distinct social structures. Race, religion, and origin shaped who held power and who was marginalized.
Common Mistakes on Comparison Questions
Summary Comparison Table
| Category | Spanish | English | French |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Goal | Wealth extraction | Settlement + profit | Fur trade |
| Labor System | Encomienda | Servitude, then slavery | Trade partnerships |
| Settlement Pattern | Few settlers, intermarriage | Families, permanent towns | Trading posts, few settlers |
| Governance | Viceroyalties (strict) | Colonial assemblies | Royal control |
| Native Relations | Subjugation, missions | Displacement, conflict | Alliances, trade |
| Religion | Catholic conversion | Protestant (diverse) | Catholic missions |
Question 1 of 5
A key similarity between Spanish and English colonial labor systems in Period 2 was that both:
Question 2 of 5
Which of the following best explains why French colonists generally maintained more cooperative relationships with Indigenous peoples than English colonists did?
Question 3 of 5
A major difference between the Chesapeake and New England colonies was their approach to governance. Which statement best describes this difference?
Question 4 of 5
Historian A: "The development of racial slavery in the English colonies was primarily an economic decision. Planters needed a permanent, controllable labor force, and enslaved Africans fulfilled that need more reliably than indentured servants."
Historian B: "Racial slavery emerged because English colonists brought deeply ingrained ideas about racial superiority from Europe. Economic motives alone cannot explain the uniquely dehumanizing character of chattel slavery."
Which comparison skill is most directly tested by analyzing these two historians' arguments?
Question 5 of 5
Which of the following is the strongest example of a comparison statement for an AP essay about Period 2 colonial societies?