01 / 20

Comparison in
Period 2

Master the AP skill of historical comparison across European colonial societies in North America, 1607 to 1754.

AP U.S. History

What Is Historical Comparison?

Historical comparison is the skill of identifying similarities and differences between two or more historical developments, events, or societies. On the AP exam, you must go beyond listing facts: you need to explain why those similarities or differences existed and what their significance was.

Why Period 2 Matters

Period 2 (1607-1754) saw multiple European powers establish colonies with vastly different goals, labor systems, and relationships with Indigenous peoples. This era is a natural testing ground for comparison because the same continent produced dramatically different colonial societies.

Spanish
Extraction of wealth, encomienda labor, Catholic missions
English
Settlement colonies, diverse economies, representative assemblies
French
Fur trade, limited settlement, alliances with Native groups

Three Empires, One Continent

Spanish Goals Gold, God, Glory Labor Encomienda system Settlement Few settlers, mostly male, intermarriage Government Viceroyalties, strict English Goals Settlement, profit, religious freedom Labor Indentured servants, then enslaved Africans Settlement Families, permanent communities Government Self-governing assemblies French Goals Fur trade, Catholic conversion Labor Coureurs de bois, Native trade partners Settlement Very few settlers, trading posts Government Royal control, no colonial assemblies

The AP Comparison Framework

The College Board tests comparison through a specific structure. Every strong comparison must include three elements:

1
Describe a similarity or difference between the two developments being compared.
2
Explain the reason for that similarity or difference using historical evidence.
3
Connect the comparison to a broader historical process, pattern, or theme.

Similarity vs. Difference

Students often default to listing differences. But the strongest AP essays also identify unexpected similarities across colonial societies. Both approaches require evidence and explanation.

Similarity Example
Both Spanish and English colonies relied on coerced labor systems (encomienda and chattel slavery) because European colonizers sought to maximize profit from land they had seized from Indigenous peoples.
Difference Example
English colonies developed representative assemblies while Spanish colonies did not, because England's tradition of parliamentary governance carried over and the Crown granted more autonomy to attract settlers.

Categories for Comparison

When comparing colonial societies in Period 2, organize your analysis around these categories. Each provides a lens for identifying meaningful similarities and differences.

Economic Systems
Cash crops, mercantilism, fur trade, subsistence farming
Labor Systems
Encomienda, slavery, indentured servitude, free labor
Social Hierarchies
Race, class, gender roles, religious authority
Relations with Natives
Alliance, warfare, trade, displacement, intermarriage

How to Write a Comparison

1
Identify your subjects: Choose two specific colonial regions, powers, or developments (e.g., Chesapeake vs. New England).
2
Choose a category: Pick a lens such as labor systems, governance, or relations with Indigenous peoples.
3
State the comparison: "A similarity/difference between X and Y was..." using clear, direct language.
4
Explain with evidence: Give the reason for the similarity or difference and cite specific historical facts.
5
Connect to a theme: Link to a broader AP theme (e.g., American and National Identity, Work, Exchange, and Technology).

Example: Chesapeake vs. New England

Chesapeake Tobacco economy Indentured servants then enslaved Africans Mostly male settlers High mortality House of Burgesses vs. New England Subsistence farming Family-based labor Limited slavery Families, communities Longer life expectancy Town meetings

Example: English vs. Spanish Labor

Both colonial powers used coerced labor, but the systems looked different. Let's walk through a full comparison.

1
Similarity: Both English and Spanish colonies relied on coerced labor to extract wealth from the land.
2
Evidence: Spain used the encomienda system to force Indigenous labor; English colonies relied on indentured servitude and later chattel slavery of Africans.
3
Explanation: Both systems arose because European colonizers needed cheap labor to make agriculture and mining profitable, but they targeted different populations due to local demographics and available labor pools.

Example: French vs. English Native Relations

French Approach
Built trade alliances with Huron and Algonquin nations. Intermarriage was common. Few settlers meant less pressure on Native lands.
English Approach
Displaced Native peoples for settlement. Wars (Pequot War, King Philip's War). Viewed Natives as obstacles to expansion.

Timeline of English Colonial Regions

1607
Jamestown (Chesapeake)
First permanent English settlement: profit-driven, tobacco economy, high mortality
1620
Plymouth (New England)
Separatist Pilgrims seeking religious freedom: communal, family-based settlement
1630
Massachusetts Bay (New England)
Puritan "city upon a hill": theocratic governance, tight-knit communities
1634
Maryland (Chesapeake)
Catholic haven founded by Lord Baltimore: tobacco, religious toleration (1649 Act)
1681
Pennsylvania (Middle Colonies)
Quaker colony: religious pluralism, diverse population, grain economy
1732
Georgia (Southern)
Buffer colony: initially banned slavery, debtor resettlement, military defense

Comparing Social Hierarchies

Each colonial power created distinct social structures. Race, religion, and origin shaped who held power and who was marginalized.

1
Spanish casta system: Elaborate racial hierarchy (peninsulares, criollos, mestizos, mulattos, Natives, Africans) based on bloodline and birthplace.
2
English racial binary: Increasingly rigid Black/white division. Bacon's Rebellion (1676) accelerated the shift from class-based to race-based hierarchy.
3
French fluid boundaries: Intermarriage with Indigenous peoples (metis) was more accepted; smaller settlements meant less rigid hierarchy.

Common Mistakes on Comparison Questions

✕ Listing Without Explaining
Simply saying "the Chesapeake grew tobacco and New England did not" without explaining why this difference existed earns no comparison point.
✕ Only Noting Differences
Strong essays identify both similarities and differences. All three colonial powers, for instance, disrupted Indigenous societies.
✕ Vague Evidence
Writing "the colonies had different economies" is too vague. Name specific systems: encomienda, indentured servitude, fur trade.

Summary Comparison Table

Category Spanish English French
Primary Goal Wealth extraction Settlement + profit Fur trade
Labor System Encomienda Servitude, then slavery Trade partnerships
Settlement Pattern Few settlers, intermarriage Families, permanent towns Trading posts, few settlers
Governance Viceroyalties (strict) Colonial assemblies Royal control
Native Relations Subjugation, missions Displacement, conflict Alliances, trade
Religion Catholic conversion Protestant (diverse) Catholic missions

Question 1 of 5

A key similarity between Spanish and English colonial labor systems in Period 2 was that both:

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following best explains why French colonists generally maintained more cooperative relationships with Indigenous peoples than English colonists did?

Question 3 of 5

A major difference between the Chesapeake and New England colonies was their approach to governance. Which statement best describes this difference?

Question 4 of 5

Which comparison skill is most directly tested by analyzing these two historians' arguments?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following is the strongest example of a comparison statement for an AP essay about Period 2 colonial societies?