01 / 22

Attribution Theory
and Person Perception

Explore how we explain behavior, form impressions of others, and navigate the cognitive biases that shape our social world.

AP Psychology

What is Attribution?

When you see someone trip on the sidewalk, your brain instantly generates an explanation: "They're clumsy" or "The pavement was uneven." This process of assigning causes to behavior is called attribution.

Attribution theory, pioneered by Fritz Heider in the 1950s, examines how ordinary people become "naive psychologists" who construct causal explanations for everyday events.

Two Types of Attributions

Dispositional (Internal)
Attributing behavior to a person's character, personality, or ability. "She aced the test because she's brilliant."
Situational (External)
Attributing behavior to environmental factors or circumstances. "She aced the test because it was easy."

Why Attribution Matters

Attribution Relationships Self-Concept Legal Judgments Emotional Reactions

The attributions we make shape our emotions, relationships, self-concept, and even legal decisions. Misattributions can lead to prejudice, conflict, and poor judgment.

Kelley's Covariation Model

Harold Kelley (1967) proposed that we use three types of information to decide whether behavior is caused by the person or the situation:

Consistency
Does this person behave this way every time in this situation?
Distinctiveness
Does this person behave this way only in this situation, or in many situations?
Consensus
Do other people also behave this way in the same situation?

Applying the Covariation Model

Consistency HIGH Distinctiveness LOW Consensus LOW Dispositional (Internal) Consistency HIGH Distinctiveness HIGH Consensus HIGH Situational (External)

The Fundamental Attribution Error

The Fundamental Attribution Error (FAE) is our tendency to overestimate dispositional factors and underestimate situational factors when explaining other people's behavior.

Person Situation Overweighted Underweighted

FAE vs. Actor-Observer Bias

Fundamental Attribution Error Actor-Observer Bias
Focus Judging others' behavior Comparing how we judge self vs. others
Bias Direction Overestimate internal causes for others Internal for others, external for self
Example "He failed because he's lazy" "He failed because he's lazy, but I failed because the test was unfair"
Scope One-directional (others only) Two-directional (self AND others)

The Self-Serving Bias

The self-serving bias is our tendency to attribute successes to internal factors (our skill, effort) and failures to external factors (bad luck, unfair circumstances).

Success → Internal
"I got an A because I studied hard and I'm smart."
Failure → External
"I got an F because the teacher writes unfair tests."

What is Person Perception?

Person perception refers to the processes by which we form impressions of other people. We integrate information from appearance, behavior, context, and prior expectations to build a mental model of who someone "is."

1
Physical cues: Appearance, facial expressions, body language
2
Behavioral cues: Actions, speech patterns, choices
3
Context: Setting, social role, group membership
4
Schemas and stereotypes: Prior knowledge and expectations

Primacy and Halo Effects

Primacy Effect
First impressions carry disproportionate weight. Information encountered early in a sequence influences overall judgment more than later information.
Halo Effect
A single positive trait (e.g., attractiveness) creates a "halo" that leads us to assume other positive qualities (e.g., intelligence, kindness).

How to Analyze Attributions

1
Identify the behavior: What specific action is being explained?
2
Determine the attribution type: Is the explanation pointing to the person (dispositional) or the situation (situational)?
3
Check for biases: Is the FAE, self-serving bias, or actor-observer bias at play?
4
Apply Kelley's model: Consider consistency, distinctiveness, and consensus to evaluate the attribution.
5
Consider culture: Individualist cultures favor internal attributions; collectivist cultures are more balanced.

Example 1: The Late Student

1
Behavior: Arriving late to class
2
Attribution type: Dispositional ("irresponsible," "doesn't care")
3
Bias present: Fundamental Attribution Error: the teacher overlooked possible situational factors (broken bus route, family issues, part-time job)

Example 2: Kelley's Model in Action

Consistency HIGH Maria always laughs Distinctiveness HIGH Only at this comedian Consensus HIGH Everyone laughs too External Attribution "The comedian is funny"

Conclusion: High consistency + high distinctiveness + high consensus = external attribution. The cause is the comedian, not Maria.

Example 3: Self-Serving Bias

Game 1: Success
Attribution: "I was in the zone" → Internal (dispositional). Attributes success to personal skill and performance.
Game 2: Failure
Attribution: "Refs were terrible" → External (situational). Blames outside forces for poor performance.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing FAE with Self-Serving Bias
FAE is about judging others. Self-serving bias is about protecting your own self-image. They overlap but are distinct concepts.
✕ Forgetting Cultural Differences
The FAE is strongest in individualist Western cultures. Collectivist cultures (e.g., Japan, China) are more likely to consider situational factors.
✕ Mixing Up Kelley's Dimensions
Consensus is about other people. Distinctiveness is about other situations. Consistency is about the same situation over time.

Summary of Key Biases

Bias Definition Key Feature
Fundamental Attribution Error Overestimate internal causes for others' behavior One-directional (others only)
Actor-Observer Bias Internal for others, external for self Two-directional (self + others)
Self-Serving Bias Credit success internally, blame failure externally Self-esteem protection
Halo Effect One positive trait colors overall impression Person perception bias
Primacy Effect First information has outsized influence Order-dependent impression

Question 1 of 5

A student fails an exam and thinks, "The test was unfair and the room was too noisy." This is an example of which type of attribution?

Question 2 of 5

According to Kelley's covariation model, if a behavior has high consistency, high distinctiveness, and high consensus, we are most likely to make which type of attribution?

Question 3 of 5

You see a stranger trip and fall in a store. You immediately think, "How clumsy." This best illustrates which concept?

Question 4 of 5

A job candidate is physically attractive, and the interviewer assumes she must also be intelligent and hardworking. This is an example of the:

Question 5 of 5

After winning a chess match, Alex says, "I played a brilliant game." After losing the next match, Alex says, "My opponent got lucky." Which bias does this illustrate?