Write Paragraphs With
Claim and Evidence
Master the art of building persuasive body paragraphs by anchoring every argument in a clear claim, supporting it with specific evidence, and connecting it back through analysis.
What Is a Claim?
A claim is a debatable statement that presents your position on a topic. It is not a fact, a question, or a summary: it is your argument distilled into one sentence. Every body paragraph in an AP essay should open with a claim that directly supports your thesis.
What Is Evidence?
Evidence is the concrete material you use to prove your claim: quotations, paraphrased details, statistics, historical examples, or observations from a source text. On the AP exam, evidence is drawn from the passage(s) provided.
Why Claim + Evidence Matters
AP readers score essays on how well you defend your argument. A paragraph without a clear claim drifts into summary; a paragraph without evidence is mere opinion. The combination is what earns you credit on the Evidence and Commentary rows of the AP rubric.
The C-E-A Paragraph Model
Claim vs. Topic Sentence
| Strong Claim | Weak Topic Sentence | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Debatable: takes a position | Descriptive: announces a topic |
| Example | "Lincoln uses antithesis to redefine national purpose." | "Lincoln uses rhetorical strategies." |
| Specificity | Names the device and its effect | Vague: names neither |
| AP Score Impact | Earns commentary credit | Reads as summary |
Choosing Effective Evidence
The Role of Analysis
Analysis is the most important and most overlooked part of a body paragraph. It answers the question: "So what?" You must explain how your evidence proves your claim and why that matters to the larger argument.
How to Write a C-E-A Paragraph
Example 1: Basic Paragraph
Example 2: Layered Evidence
Example 3: Sophisticated Commentary
In an advanced paragraph, your analysis does more than explain: it evaluates, qualifies, or complicates. Notice how the analysis below introduces a tension rather than just restating the claim.
Embedding Evidence Smoothly
Never "drop" a quotation into your paragraph without introduction. Use signal phrases to weave the evidence into your own syntax.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Paragraph Quality Levels
| Score 1-2 | Score 3 | Score 4 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Missing or restates prompt | Present but generic | Specific, arguable, precise |
| Evidence | Absent or irrelevant | Present but broad | Specific, well-chosen, embedded |
| Analysis | Absent: "hit and run" evidence | Explains evidence surface-level | Interprets, complicates, connects to thesis |
| Coherence | Jumps between ideas | Follows C-E-A but formulaic | Fluid: each sentence builds on the last |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following best describes the role of a claim in a body paragraph?
Question 2 of 5
Student paragraph: "Fitzgerald uses the green light. 'He stretched out his arms toward the dark water.' The green light represents Gatsby's dream."
What is the primary weakness of this paragraph?
Question 3 of 5
Which sentence is the best example of analysis (not summary or evidence)?
Question 4 of 5
A student writes: "The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here." Lincoln uses language in his speech. What is wrong with the sentence following the quotation?
Question 5 of 5
In the C-E-A model, what is the purpose of the final linking sentence in a body paragraph?