Identify and Describe
Writer/Speaker
Learn to recognize who is communicating, understand their rhetorical context, and describe how identity shapes argument.
What Does "Identify the Writer/Speaker" Mean?
Every text is produced by someone: a real person with a background, set of beliefs, social position, and purpose. On the AP exam, your first job is to figure out who that person is and what context they bring to their argument.
Why Does the Writer/Speaker Matter?
The Rhetorical Situation Framework
The Identification Framework
When the AP exam asks you to identify and describe the writer/speaker, you need to address four dimensions of their identity:
Writer vs. Speaker vs. Narrator
| Writer | Speaker | Narrator | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medium | Written text | Spoken/transcribed | Fictional voice |
| Identity | Real person | Real person | Created persona |
| Accountability | Directly responsible | Directly responsible | Author is responsible |
| AP Focus | Essays, articles | Speeches, letters | Rarely tested in Lang |
Stated vs. Implied Identity
How to Identify the Writer/Speaker
Example 1: Frederick Douglass
Example 2: Rachel Carson
Example 3: An Anonymous Editorial
Sometimes the writer is unnamed. An unsigned editorial in The New York Times (2018) argued for stricter gun control after a school shooting. How do you identify the "writer" here?
Textual Signals to Look For
How to Describe the Writer Effectively
In your AP essay, don't just name the writer. Describe them in a way that connects to their argument. Use this formula:
Using the SOAPSTone Framework
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Summary: Writer/Speaker Identification
| Dimension | What to Find | Where to Look |
|---|---|---|
| Identity | Name, role, social position | Intro, footnotes, bylines |
| Credentials | Expertise, experience, authority | Self-references, credentials cited |
| Values | Beliefs, ideology, assumptions | Diction, framing, evidence chosen |
| Stake | What they gain or lose | Tone, urgency, personal anecdotes |
| Purpose | Goal of the argument | Thesis, conclusion, calls to action |
Question 1 of 5
A passage begins with the footnote: "Delivered by Sojourner Truth at the Women's Convention in Akron, Ohio, 1851." Which aspect of the speaker's identity is most directly established by this information?
Question 2 of 5
"I have spent the better part of three decades in the emergency room, and I have watched this epidemic claim lives that no statistic can adequately represent. Each body is someone's child. I did not enter medicine to fill out death certificates."
Which characteristic of the writer/speaker is most clearly implied by this excerpt?
Question 3 of 5
A student writes: "The author argues for environmental protection." How could this sentence be improved to better identify and describe the writer?
Question 4 of 5
An unsigned editorial in a major newspaper uses phrases like "our democratic institutions" and "we must act now." What does this language most reveal about the speaker's identity?
Question 5 of 5
Speaker A: "As someone who immigrated to this country at the age of six, I understand the terror of uncertainty. My family left everything behind for a promise. That promise must be kept."
Speaker B: "Immigration policy must be governed by data, not sentiment. Studies show that controlled immigration benefits GDP growth by 0.3% annually."
Which of the following best describes the key difference in how these two speakers establish their identity?