01 / 22

The Practice of
Political Scientists

Explore how political scientists study, compare, and analyze governments using systematic methods, empirical evidence, and theoretical frameworks.

AP Comparative Government & Politics

What Is Political Science?

Political science is the systematic study of politics, power, and government. Unlike casual opinions about politics, political scientists use rigorous methods to ask questions, gather evidence, and draw conclusions about how governments work and why they differ.

Core Concepts in the Discipline

Empirical Analysis
Drawing conclusions from observable data and real-world evidence rather than ideology
Normative Analysis
Evaluating what governments should do based on values, ethics, and ideals
Comparative Method
Examining similarities and differences across countries to identify patterns and causal relationships

Why Does It Matter?

Political scientists inform policy, strengthen democratic institutions, and help citizens understand the forces shaping their lives. Their work answers questions like: Why do some democracies endure while others collapse? What makes economic development succeed in certain countries?

1
Explains political behavior: Why people vote, protest, or comply with authority.
2
Evaluates institutions: Whether constitutions, legislatures, and courts function as designed.
3
Informs policy decisions: Evidence-based recommendations for governments and international organizations.

The Comparative Method

Country A Democracy Country B Authoritarian Compare Causal Insights & Patterns

Empirical vs. Normative Questions

Empirical Normative
Focus What is What should be
Method Data, observation, testing Values, ethics, philosophy
Example "Does voter turnout rise with education?" "Should voting be mandatory?"
Testable? Yes No (value judgment)

Research Methods Overview

Research Methods Quantitative Surveys, statistical analysis, large datasets Qualitative Interviews, case studies, ethnography, textual analysis Comparative Cross-national studies, most similar/different design Evidence-Based Conclusions

Quantitative vs. Qualitative

Quantitative
Uses numbers and statistics to identify patterns. Example: analyzing voter turnout percentages across 50 countries to find correlations with GDP per capita.
Qualitative
Uses words and context to build deep understanding. Example: interviewing activists in Nigeria to understand why civil society emerged despite authoritarian rule.

Causation vs. Correlation

Correlation Two variables move together (A and B linked) Causation One variable directly produces the other (A → B) vs. Key Rule for AP Exam Correlation does NOT imply causation.

Variables in Political Research

Independent Variable
The cause or factor being studied. It is manipulated or observed to see its effect. Example: level of economic development.
Dependent Variable
The outcome being measured. It changes in response to the independent variable. Example: degree of democratization.

How Political Scientists Analyze

1
Ask a research question: Frame a clear, testable question about government or political behavior.
2
Form a hypothesis: Propose an expected relationship between an independent and dependent variable.
3
Select cases: Choose countries or units to compare using the most similar or most different systems design.
4
Gather evidence: Collect quantitative data (e.g., election results) and qualitative data (e.g., interviews).
5
Draw conclusions: Analyze evidence to support or refute the hypothesis, acknowledging limitations.

Most Similar vs. Most Different

Most Similar Systems Most Different Systems
Logic Compare similar countries with different outcomes Compare different countries with the same outcome
Goal Isolate what differs between them Isolate what they share
Example UK vs. Nigeria: both ex-British colonies, different democracy levels China vs. Iran: very different, both authoritarian

Example: Analyzing Democracy

A political scientist asks: "Why is the UK a stable democracy while Nigeria experiences democratic instability?"

1
Design: Most Similar Systems: both are former British colonies with common-law traditions.
2
Independent variable: Level of ethnic fragmentation and oil dependence.
3
Dependent variable: Democratic stability (measured by years of uninterrupted civilian rule).
4
Conclusion: High ethnic division and resource dependence correlate with democratic instability.

Example: Authoritarian Persistence

A researcher investigates: "Why do China and Iran both maintain authoritarian control despite very different cultures and economies?"

Example: Evaluating a Claim

A politician claims: "Countries with more internet access always become more democratic." How would a political scientist evaluate this?

1
Identify the hypothesis: Internet access (independent) causes democratization (dependent).
2
Find counterexamples: China has high internet access but strict censorship and no democratization.
3
Identify confounds: State censorship capacity, civil society strength, and regime type mediate the relationship.
4
Conclusion: The claim confuses correlation with causation. Internet access is neither necessary nor sufficient for democratization.

Common Mistakes

✕ Correlation = Causation
Assuming that because two trends move together, one must cause the other. Always look for confounding variables.
✕ Mixing Empirical and Normative
Confusing factual claims ("Democracy reduces corruption") with value judgments ("Democracy is the best system").
✕ Reversing Variables
Misidentifying which variable is independent (the cause) and which is dependent (the outcome) in a research design.

Summary: Key Concepts

Concept Definition Example
Empirical Based on observable evidence Measuring voter turnout
Normative Based on values and ideals "Voting should be compulsory"
Independent Var. The suspected cause Level of education
Dependent Var. The measured outcome Political participation
Correlation Two variables move together GDP and democracy scores
Causation One variable produces another Education causes higher turnout

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following is an empirical question?

Question 2 of 5

A researcher compares the UK and Nigeria to understand why their democratic outcomes differ. This is an example of:

Question 3 of 5

In the hypothesis "Economic development leads to democratization," which is the dependent variable?

Question 4 of 5

A study finds that countries with more cell phones also have higher life expectancy. A student concludes: "Cell phones cause longer lives." What is the flaw in this reasoning?

Question 5 of 5

Scholar A and Scholar B would most likely agree on which of the following?