01 / 20

Political & Social
Cleavages

Explore how deep divisions in society shape political behavior, party systems, and government stability across the world.

AP Comparative Government

What Is a Cleavage?

In comparative politics, a cleavage is a deep and persistent division in society that shapes political identities and conflicts. Unlike temporary disagreements, cleavages are structural: they are rooted in history, economics, culture, or demographics and endure across generations.

Major Types of Cleavages

Ethnic / Racial
Divisions based on ethnicity, race, or tribal identity (e.g., Nigeria's Hausa-Fulani, Yoruba, Igbo)
Religious
Conflicts between religious groups or secular vs. religious visions of governance (e.g., Iran)
Class / Economic
Rich vs. poor, workers vs. owners, urban professionals vs. rural laborers (e.g., UK Labour vs. Tories)
Regional / Geographic
Center vs. periphery tensions, urban vs. rural divides (e.g., Russia's Moscow vs. regions)
Gender
Differences in political participation, representation, and policy priorities between genders
Ideological
Left vs. right, authoritarian vs. democratic, reform vs. status quo orientations

Why Cleavages Matter

Cleavages determine how citizens align politically, which parties form, and whether conflict is managed peacefully or erupts into violence. Understanding cleavages is essential for comparing political systems across AP Comparative Government's six core countries.

1
Shape party systems: Parties often emerge to represent one side of a cleavage (e.g., Labour for workers, Conservatives for business owners).
2
Influence policy: Governments must address or manage cleavage-based demands through policy (e.g., affirmative action, federalism).
3
Affect stability: Unmanaged cleavages can lead to civil war, secessionism, or regime collapse. Managed ones can strengthen democracy.

The Lipset-Rokkan Framework

Political scientists Seymour Martin Lipset and Stein Rokkan (1967) identified four foundational cleavages that shaped European party systems. These emerged from two great revolutions: the National Revolution and the Industrial Revolution.

National Revolution Center vs. Periphery Church vs. State Language, culture Religion, secularism Industrial Revolution Urban vs. Rural Owner vs. Worker Economic interests Class conflict Party Systems "Frozen" by 1920s Cleavages become institutionalized in parties "Freezing hypothesis": parties reflect historic divisions

Cross-cutting vs. Coinciding Cleavages

Cross-cutting
Different cleavages divide people in different ways, creating overlapping group memberships. A Catholic worker might share religion with a Catholic business owner but share class interests with a Protestant worker. This moderates conflict.
Coinciding (Reinforcing)
Multiple cleavages overlap and reinforce each other. If one ethnic group is also the poorest, least educated, and regionally concentrated, all divisions stack up. This intensifies conflict and threatens stability.

How States Manage Cleavages

1
Federalism: Grants regional autonomy to minority groups (e.g., Nigeria's 36 states, Russia's federal subjects, Mexico's states).
2
Consociationalism: Power-sharing arrangements ensuring all major groups are represented in government (e.g., Nigeria's zoning principle).
3
Electoral systems: Proportional representation can give voice to smaller groups; FPTP may marginalize them.
4
Suppression: Authoritarian regimes may suppress cleavage expression entirely (e.g., China's treatment of ethnic minorities, Iran's handling of ethnic Kurds).
5
Co-optation: Incorporating group leaders into the regime without genuine power-sharing (e.g., corporatism in Mexico under PRI).

Visualizing Cleavage Patterns

Cross-cutting Ethnic divide Class divide Mixed memberships Coinciding Group A Ethnic + Class + Region Group B Ethnic + Class + Region All divides overlap

How to Apply Cleavage Analysis

1
Identify the cleavage: What social division exists? Is it ethnic, religious, class, regional, or ideological?
2
Determine salience: How politically important is this division? Does it influence voting, protests, or policy?
3
Classify the pattern: Are cleavages cross-cutting (reducing tension) or coinciding (intensifying it)?
4
Analyze management: How does the state respond? Federalism, power-sharing, suppression, or co-optation?
5
Evaluate outcomes: Has the strategy promoted stability, or has it failed (leading to violence, separatism, or authoritarianism)?

Example: Nigeria

Muslim North Hausa-Fulani Sharia law in 12 states Rural, less developed Christian South Yoruba & Igbo Oil-producing region More urbanized Coinciding Cleavages Ethnicity + Religion + Region + Class All reinforce the same North-South divide

Example: United Kingdom

The UK demonstrates how cleavages evolve over time. The traditional class cleavage (working class → Labour, upper/middle class → Conservative) has weakened since the 1980s. New cleavages have emerged:

Class (declining)
Once dominant: miners and factory workers voted Labour; professionals voted Tory. Now blurred by deindustrialization and social mobility.
Brexit / Values
The 2016 referendum created a new cleavage: Leave (nationalist, anti-immigration) vs. Remain (cosmopolitan, pro-EU). Cut across old party lines.
Regional / National
Scotland's independence movement (SNP) and devolution reflect a center-periphery cleavage between London/England and Celtic nations.

Examples: China & Iran

China
The CCP suppresses open cleavage expression. Key underlying divisions: urban vs. rural (coastal cities vs. interior), Han vs. ethnic minorities (Uyghurs, Tibetans), and growing class inequality. The party manages these through censorship, economic development, and coercion.
Iran
Iran's key cleavages: reformists vs. hardliners (ideological), Persian vs. non-Persian ethnicities (Azeri, Kurdish, Arab), secular-minded youth vs. clerical establishment, and urban vs. rural. The Guardian Council manages these by controlling who can run for office.

Examples: Russia & Mexico

Russia
Center vs. periphery: Moscow dominates, while regions like Chechnya seek autonomy. Ethnic diversity: Over 100 ethnic groups, managed through asymmetric federalism. Class: Oligarchs vs. ordinary citizens. Putin suppresses political expression of cleavages.
Mexico
Class inequality: Extreme wealth gap between elite and rural/indigenous poor. Regional: Wealthy North vs. poorer South. Indigenous vs. mestizo: Zapatista movement in Chiapas. The PRI historically co-opted groups through corporatism; MORENA now mobilizes the poor.

Common Mistakes

✕ Cleavage = Disagreement
A cleavage is structural and persistent, not just any political disagreement. A debate over a single bill is not a cleavage. Decades of class conflict is.
✕ Ignoring Regime Type
Students often analyze all countries as if they were democracies. In authoritarian systems, cleavages still exist but are suppressed, not freely expressed through parties.
✕ Confusing Cross-cutting with Absent
Cross-cutting does not mean cleavages don't exist. It means they pull people in different directions, reducing the intensity of any single division.

Cleavages Across AP Countries

Country Primary Cleavage Pattern Management
UK Class, Brexit values Cross-cutting Parties, devolution
Nigeria Ethnic-religious-regional Coinciding Federalism, zoning
China Urban-rural, ethnic Suppressed Censorship, coercion
Iran Reformist-hardliner, ethnic Channeled Guardian Council vetting
Russia Center-periphery, ethnic Suppressed Asymmetric federalism
Mexico Class, indigenous, regional Mixed Corporatism, parties

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes a political cleavage?

Question 2 of 5

Nigeria is often cited as having coinciding cleavages. What does this mean?

Question 3 of 5

According to Lipset and Rokkan, which pair of revolutions produced the four foundational cleavages in European party systems?

Question 4 of 5

How does China's authoritarian government primarily handle political and social cleavages?

Question 5 of 5

Which scenario best illustrates cross-cutting cleavages?