01 / 21

Legislative
Systems

Explore how parliaments and congresses shape law-making across the world: from unicameral to bicameral structures, fused vs. separated powers, and everything in between.

AP Comparative Government

What Is a Legislature?

A legislature is the branch of government responsible for making, amending, and repealing laws. It serves as the primary institution of representative democracy, translating the will of citizens into binding policy.

Core Functions of Legislatures

Law-Making
Draft, debate, amend, and pass legislation that becomes binding on the state.
Representation
Channel citizen interests into policy through elected or appointed members.
Oversight
Scrutinize the executive branch through hearings, questions, and investigations.
Budget Control
Approve or reject government spending: the "power of the purse."

Why This Matters for the Exam

The AP Comparative Government exam tests your ability to compare legislative structures across the six core countries: UK, Russia, China, Iran, Mexico, and Nigeria. You must analyze how structural differences affect policy outcomes, executive power, and democratic accountability.

Unicameral vs. Bicameral

Unicameral Single Chamber All law-making in one body Bicameral Upper House Lower House Bills must pass both chambers (usually) vs.

Fused vs. Separated Powers

Fused Powers (Parliamentary System) Legislature selects Executive (PM + Cabinet) accountable to Legislature UK model Separated Powers (Presidential System) Legislature Executive (President) Voters elect elect independent Mexico & Nigeria model

Parliamentary vs. Presidential

Feature Parliamentary Presidential
Executive Selection Chosen by legislature Elected independently
Vote of No Confidence Yes No (impeachment only)
Dissolution Power PM can dissolve parliament Fixed terms: no dissolution
Cabinet Members Usually MPs (from legislature) Appointed: not in legislature
AP Example UK Mexico, Nigeria

Upper vs. Lower Houses

Upper House
Often represents regions or states. May be appointed or indirectly elected. Examples: UK House of Lords, Russian Federation Council, Mexican Senate.
Lower House
Directly elected by the people. Usually has the primary law-making power and controls the budget. Examples: UK House of Commons, Russian State Duma, Nigerian House of Representatives.

How to Analyze a Legislative System

1
Structure: Is it unicameral or bicameral? If bicameral, which chamber dominates?
2
Selection method: Are members elected directly, indirectly, or appointed? What electoral system is used?
3
Relationship with executive: Fused powers (parliamentary) or separated (presidential)? Can the legislature remove the executive?
4
Effective power: Does the legislature genuinely shape policy, or does the executive dominate? (Rubber stamp vs. independent)
5
Compare: How does this system differ from other AP countries? What outcomes does the structure produce?

Example: UK Parliament

House of Commons 650 MPs, directly elected (FPTP) House of Lords ~800 members, appointed/hereditary Prime Minister + Cabinet Must maintain Commons confidence selects PM revises bills Voters elect

Example: Mexico's Congress

Senate 128 Senators, mixed election Chamber of Deputies 500 Deputies, mixed (300 SMD + 200 PR) President Elected independently, single 6-year term independent branches Voters elect all three separately

Example: China's NPC

Chinese Communist Party National People's Congress ~2,980 deputies, meets ~2 weeks/year NPC Standing Committee ~175 members, exercises real power controls delegates to Unicameral "rubber stamp" legislature

Example: Iran's Majles

Majles (Parliament)
290 members, directly elected. It can pass laws, approve budgets, and question ministers. Unicameral structure.
Guardian Council
12 members (6 clerics + 6 jurists). Vets all candidates and can reject any law it deems un-Islamic or unconstitutional.

Russia and Nigeria

Russia: Federal Assembly
Bicameral. State Duma (450, mixed-member election) + Federation Council (appointed by regions). In practice, the Duma is heavily influenced by United Russia and the president. Limited genuine opposition.
Nigeria: National Assembly
Bicameral. Senate (109, 3 per state + 1 FCT) + House of Representatives (360, FPTP). More independent than Russia's: legislators often defy the president on budget and appointments.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing Structure with Power
A bicameral legislature isn't automatically more powerful. China's unicameral NPC is constitutionally supreme but practically weak. Nigeria's bicameral system is actually more independent.
✕ Ignoring Informal Constraints
Iran's Majles and Russia's Duma look democratic on paper, but the Guardian Council and executive dominance, respectively, severely limit their real power. Always distinguish de jure from de facto.
✕ Treating All Bicameral Systems Alike
The UK's House of Lords is unelected and weak. Mexico's Senate is elected and co-equal on many issues. Always specify how the second chamber is composed and what powers it holds.

Six-Country Comparison

Country Structure System Type Real Power
UK Bicameral Parliamentary High (Commons)
Russia Bicameral Semi-presidential Low
China Unicameral One-party state Very low
Iran Unicameral Theocratic hybrid Low-medium
Mexico Bicameral Presidential Medium-high
Nigeria Bicameral Presidential Medium-high

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes the relationship between the executive and the legislature in a parliamentary system?

Question 2 of 5

China's National People's Congress is often described as a "rubber stamp" legislature. Which of the following best supports this characterization?

Question 3 of 5

In Iran, the Guardian Council limits the power of the Majles primarily by:

Question 4 of 5

A key difference between Mexico's and the UK's legislative systems is that:

Question 5 of 5

Based on the descriptions above, which of the following conclusions is most supported?