01 / 21

Judicial
Systems

Explore how courts operate across the world: from judicial review and constitutional courts to code law vs. common law traditions and the balance of judicial independence.

AP Comparative Government

What Is a Judicial System?

A judicial system is the network of courts and legal institutions within a state that interprets laws, resolves disputes, and holds government accountable. It is one of the three branches of government, alongside the executive and legislature.

Essential Key Terms

Judicial Review
The power of courts to declare laws or executive actions unconstitutional
Rule of Law
The principle that all individuals and institutions are subject to law equally applied
Judicial Independence
The degree to which judges can make decisions free from political pressure
Constitutional Court
A specialized court that rules on constitutional matters, separate from ordinary courts
Precedent
A previous court decision that guides future rulings: central to common law systems

Why Judiciaries Matter

Legislature Makes Laws Executive Enforces Laws Judiciary Interprets Laws Rule of Law Separation of Powers

Common Law vs. Code Law

The two major legal traditions in comparative politics are common law (case-based, judge-made) and code law (statute-based, codified). Understanding which tradition a country follows explains how courts operate and how much power judges hold.

Common Law Code Law (Civil Law)
Origin England Roman / Napoleonic tradition
Primary Source Judicial precedent Comprehensive legal codes
Judge's Role Interprets and creates law Applies existing code strictly
AP Countries UK, Nigeria Russia, China, Mexico, Iran
Flexibility High: evolves via cases Lower: requires legislative reform

The Power of Judicial Review

Judicial review is the authority of courts to examine government actions and legislation and to invalidate those that conflict with the constitution. Not every country grants this power equally.

No Review Strong Review China Iran Russia UK Nigeria Mexico Spectrum of Judicial Review Power Across AP6 Countries (UK can declare "incompatibility" but cannot strike down Acts of Parliament)

Constitutional Courts

Many code law countries create a separate constitutional court rather than giving the highest ordinary court the power of judicial review. This court exists solely to rule on constitutional questions.

Russia
The Constitutional Court has 11 judges appointed by the Federation Council on the president's nomination. In practice, it has limited independence.
Mexico
The Supreme Court of Justice (SCJN) acts as both the highest court and a constitutional tribunal, with strong amparo protections for rights.

Measuring Judicial Independence

Judicial independence varies dramatically across the AP6 countries. Several factors determine how free judges are to make impartial decisions.

1
Appointment method: Are judges chosen by merit-based commissions or by political leaders?
2
Tenure security: Do judges serve for life, fixed terms, or "at the pleasure" of the executive?
3
Enforcement power: Can courts compel the executive to comply with rulings?
4
Financial autonomy: Does the judiciary control its own budget, or does the executive allocate it?

Abstract vs. Concrete Review

Abstract Review Concrete Review
Timing Before a law takes effect After a law is applied to a case
Who Can Petition Government officials, parliament Any affected citizen or party
Purpose Preventive: stop unconstitutional law Corrective: remedy harm from law
Example Russia's Constitutional Court Mexico's amparo system

How to Analyze a Judiciary

1
Identify the legal tradition: Is the country common law or code law? This determines the role of precedent vs. statutes.
2
Determine the review mechanism: Does the country have judicial review? Is it abstract, concrete, or both?
3
Assess independence: How are judges appointed? Can they be removed? Are rulings enforced?
4
Evaluate effectiveness: Does the judiciary actually constrain government power, or does it serve as a rubber stamp?
5
Compare across countries: Use the AP6 framework to draw meaningful contrasts and identify patterns.

Case Study: The United Kingdom

Parliament Sovereign Lawmaker UK Supreme Court Est. 2009 (12 Justices) ✓ Can Do Declare law "incompatible" with Human Rights Act ✕ Cannot Do Strike down Acts of Parliament (no veto power)

Case Study: Russia

Structure
Constitutional Court (11 judges) plus a separate Supreme Court for civil and criminal matters. Code law tradition inherited from Soviet era.
Independence
Judges nominated by the president, confirmed by Federation Council. In practice, courts defer heavily to presidential power: a pattern called "telephone justice".

Mexico and Iran: A Contrast

Mexico Iran
Highest Court Supreme Court of Justice (SCJN) Head of Judiciary (appointed by Supreme Leader)
Review Type Concrete (amparo) Guardian Council screens laws
Independence Moderate: judges serve 15-year terms Low: Supreme Leader controls appointments
Religion's Role Secular constitution Sharia law integrated into legal code
Key Feature Amparo: individual rights protection Guardian Council: 12 members vet all legislation

China and Nigeria

China
No independent judicial review. The National People's Congress (NPC) interprets the constitution. Courts serve the Chinese Communist Party. Judges are party members selected for loyalty.
Nigeria
Federal judiciary with a Supreme Court that exercises judicial review. Blends common law, customary law, and Sharia courts (in the north). Independence is growing but faces corruption challenges.

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ UK Has Judicial Review
The UK Supreme Court cannot strike down laws. It can only issue "declarations of incompatibility." Parliamentary sovereignty prevails.
✕ All Courts Are Independent
De jure independence (written in constitution) does not equal de facto independence. Russia and China have courts on paper that defer to the executive.
✕ Confusing Iran's Courts
Iran's Guardian Council is not a court: it is a political-religious body. The actual judiciary is separate but still subordinate to the Supreme Leader.

AP6 Judicial Systems Summary

Country Legal Tradition Review Type Independence
UK Common law Limited High
Russia Code law Abstract Low (de facto)
China Code law None (NPC) Very Low
Mexico Code law Concrete (amparo) Moderate
Iran Code + Sharia Guardian Council Low
Nigeria Common + Custom + Sharia Concrete Growing

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes the principle of judicial review?

Question 2 of 5

In which AP6 country does the legislature, rather than a court, hold the power to interpret the constitution?

Question 3 of 5

Mexico's amparo system is best classified as an example of which type of judicial review?

Question 4 of 5

The passage best illustrates which concept in comparative politics?

Question 5 of 5

Which of the following correctly distinguishes the UK Supreme Court from Mexico's Supreme Court of Justice (SCJN)?