Electoral Systems
and Rules
Explore how votes become seats, compare majoritarian and proportional systems, and understand the rules that shape democratic representation worldwide.
What Is an Electoral System?
An electoral system is the set of rules that determines how votes cast by citizens are translated into seats in a legislature or positions of power. These rules dictate who can vote, how votes are counted, and how winners are determined.
Why Do Electoral Systems Matter?
The Three Major Families
First Past the Post: Winner Takes All
In a Single-Member District Plurality (SMDP) system, also called First Past the Post (FPTP), each district elects one representative. The candidate with the most votes wins: no majority is required.
Proportional Representation: Seats Match Votes
In Proportional Representation (PR), multi-member districts allocate seats based on each party's share of the vote. If a party wins 30% of the vote, it receives approximately 30% of the seats.
Mixed Systems: Best of Both?
Mixed electoral systems combine elements of majoritarian and proportional systems. Voters typically cast two ballots: one for a district representative and one for a party list.
Majoritarian vs. Proportional
| Majoritarian (FPTP) | Proportional (PR) | |
|---|---|---|
| District Type | Single-member | Multi-member |
| How Winner is Decided | Plurality (most votes) | Vote share = seat share |
| Party System Tendency | Two-party | Multi-party |
| Government Formation | Single-party majority | Coalition governments |
| Minority Representation | Lower | Higher |
| Constituency Link | Strong (local MP) | Weaker (party list) |
Electoral Rules Beyond Counting
Electoral systems encompass more than just vote-counting formulas. A complete analysis considers the full set of rules governing elections:
How to Analyze an Electoral System
Example: The United Kingdom
Example: Mexico's Parallel System
Mexico's Chamber of Deputies uses a parallel (MMM) system: 300 seats from FPTP single-member districts plus 200 seats from proportional party lists. The two tiers operate independently.
Example: Russia's Controlled Elections
Russia's State Duma uses a parallel system: 225 FPTP seats plus 225 PR seats with a \( 5\% \) threshold. However, electoral rules interact with authoritarian practices to produce specific outcomes.
The Two-Round System
Some countries use a two-round (runoff) system for executive elections. If no candidate wins a majority in the first round, the top two candidates face a second round.
AP Six Countries: Electoral Systems
| Country | Legislature | System | President |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK | FPTP (650 SMDs) | Majoritarian | N/A (PM) |
| Russia | Parallel (225+225) | Mixed | Two-round |
| China | Indirect election | Non-competitive | N/A (selected) |
| Mexico | Parallel (300+200) | Mixed | FPTP (1 round) |
| Iran | Two-round majority | Majoritarian | Two-round |
| Nigeria | FPTP | Majoritarian | FPTP + spread |
Common Mistakes
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following best describes Duverger's Law?
Question 2 of 5
Mexico's Chamber of Deputies has 500 seats: 300 elected by FPTP and 200 by proportional representation. What type of electoral system is this?
Question 3 of 5
A country's proportional representation system requires parties to win at least \( 5\% \) of the national vote to gain seats in the legislature. What is the primary purpose of this rule?
Question 4 of 5
Scenario: In Country X, three parties compete in a single-member district. Party A receives \( 38\% \) of the vote, Party B receives \( 34\% \), and Party C receives \( 28\% \). Under FPTP rules, Party A's candidate is declared the winner and takes the seat.
Which of the following is a valid criticism of this outcome?
Question 5 of 5
Which AP Comparative Government country uses indirect, non-competitive elections for its national legislature?