01 / 20

Change in Power
and Authority

Explore how governments gain, maintain, and lose political power through revolutions, reforms, and institutional change across the world's political systems.

AP Comparative Government

What Is Political Power?

Political power is the ability to influence or control the behavior of people and institutions within a political system. It determines who makes decisions, how resources are distributed, and whose interests are served.

Power
The ability to get others to do what you want, even against their will.
Authority
Power that is recognized as rightful and legitimate by those who are governed.
Legitimacy
The belief among citizens that the government has the right to rule.

Sources of Legitimacy

Max Weber identified three ideal types of legitimate authority. Understanding these helps explain why citizens obey governments and how power transitions occur.

1
Traditional Authority: Based on long-established customs and hereditary succession (e.g., monarchies in the UK and Saudi Arabia).
2
Charismatic Authority: Based on the personal appeal and extraordinary qualities of a leader (e.g., Mao Zedong, Nelson Mandela).
3
Rational-Legal Authority: Based on established laws, constitutions, and institutional rules (e.g., democratic elections in Mexico and Nigeria).

Why Does Power Change?

Power shifts occur when the existing political order fails to maintain legitimacy. Several forces drive these transitions across different political systems.

Power Change Economic Crisis Social Movements External Pressure Military Coup Elite Fracture

Mechanisms of Political Change

Political scientists categorize power transitions into four primary mechanisms. Each differs in speed, scope, and the degree of violence involved.

Revolution
Rapid, fundamental change that overthrows the existing political order entirely.
Coup d'Etat
Sudden seizure of power by a small elite group, often the military, without mass participation.
Reform
Gradual, legal modifications within the existing system to address demands for change.
Foreign Intervention
External forces impose political change through invasion, sanctions, or diplomatic pressure.

Revolution vs. Reform

The AP exam frequently tests the distinction between revolution and reform. Both change the political order, but they differ in nearly every dimension.

Revolution Reform
Speed Rapid, sudden Gradual, incremental
Scope Total system change Partial adjustments
Violence Often violent Generally peaceful
Legality Extralegal Within existing law
Participation Mass mobilization Elite-driven or institutional
AP Example Chinese Revolution (1949) Mexico's democratization

How to Analyze Power Change

Use this step-by-step framework when answering AP Comparative Government FRQs and MCQs about changes in power and authority.

1
Identify the regime type: Was it authoritarian, democratic, or hybrid before the change?
2
Determine the mechanism: Was the change a revolution, coup, reform, or foreign intervention?
3
Analyze the causes: What triggered the change: economic crisis, legitimacy failure, social movement, or elite fracture?
4
Assess the outcome: Did the change lead to democratization, new authoritarianism, or instability?
5
Compare across countries: Link the case to at least one of the AP six core countries for comparative analysis.

Case Study: China

China illustrates revolutionary change followed by reform from above. The Communist Party has maintained power while dramatically transforming economic policy.

1949
Communist Revolution
Mao Zedong's CCP overthrows the Nationalist government; establishes the People's Republic of China.
1966
Cultural Revolution
Mao uses charismatic authority to purge political rivals and enforce ideological conformity.
1978
Deng Xiaoping's Reforms
Economic liberalization begins: "Reform and Opening Up" introduces market mechanisms while maintaining CCP political control.
1989
Tiananmen Square
Pro-democracy protests suppressed by force; CCP reasserts authoritarian control over political expression.
2012+
Xi Jinping Era
Power consolidation: removal of presidential term limits, anti-corruption campaign concentrates authority.

Case Study: Mexico

Mexico demonstrates gradual democratic reform from a dominant-party authoritarian system. The PRI's 71-year grip on power ended through institutional change, not revolution.

PRI Dominance
The Institutional Revolutionary Party ruled from 1929 to 2000 using corporatism, patronage, and controlled elections.
Electoral Reform
Creation of the independent IFE (now INE) in 1990 made elections fairer and more transparent over time.
2000 Transition
Vicente Fox (PAN) won the presidency, marking the first democratic transfer of power in Mexico's modern history.

Case Study: Iran

Iran's 1979 Islamic Revolution replaced a secular monarchy with a theocratic republic. It is the AP course's primary example of revolutionary change driven by religious ideology.

1
Shah's Modernization: Rapid Westernization alienated both traditional clerics and the urban poor, eroding legitimacy.
2
Charismatic Leadership: Ayatollah Khomeini mobilized mass support using religious authority and anti-Western rhetoric.
3
Theocratic Constitution: The new system established velayat-e faqih (guardianship of the jurist), blending religious and political authority.
4
Dual Authority: Iran's system balances elected institutions (president, Majlis) with unelected religious bodies (Supreme Leader, Guardian Council).

Case Study: Nigeria

Nigeria exemplifies cyclical instability: alternating between civilian rule and military coups. Its transition to democracy remains fragile and contested.

Civilian Rule Military Coup Military Rule Transition Legitimacy crisis Consolidation Pressure for democracy Elections held

Case Study: Russia

Russia demonstrates democratic backsliding: an initial democratic transition that reversed into competitive authoritarianism under Putin's consolidation of power.

1991 Collapse
The Soviet Union dissolved, creating a new Russian state with democratic aspirations but weak institutions.
Yeltsin Era
Economic "shock therapy" caused widespread poverty; 1993 constitutional crisis ended with tanks shelling parliament.
Putin's Consolidation
Since 2000: media control, elimination of gubernatorial elections, suppression of opposition, and constitutional changes enabling extended rule.

The UK: Evolutionary Change

The United Kingdom represents the most gradual pathway to democratic governance. Power shifted from the monarchy to Parliament over centuries without a single definitive revolution.

1215
Magna Carta
Established the principle that the monarch is subject to law.
1689
Bill of Rights
After the Glorious Revolution, Parliament's supremacy over the Crown was codified.
1832
Great Reform Act
Expanded suffrage beyond the aristocracy, beginning mass democratization.
1997+
Devolution
Power transferred to Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, decentralizing UK authority.

Democratization vs. Backsliding

Power changes can move in either direction. Comparative analysis requires understanding both the forces that build democracy and those that erode it.

Democratization Backsliding
Direction Toward greater openness Toward concentrated power
Institutions Strengthened, independent Weakened, co-opted
Civil Society Expanding, free Restricted, repressed
Media Independent, diverse State-controlled or censored
AP Example Mexico (1990s-2000) Russia (2000-present)

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing Coup and Revolution
A coup is elite-driven with limited participation. A revolution involves mass mobilization and fundamental systemic change.
✕ Assuming Democratization Is Permanent
Russia shows that democratic transitions can reverse. Always consider the possibility of backsliding in your analysis.
✕ Ignoring Legitimacy Sources
Power changes are not just about force. Connect each case to Weber's legitimacy types: traditional, charismatic, or rational-legal.

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best describes Mexico's transition to democracy in 2000?

Question 2 of 5

Iran's Supreme Leader derives political authority primarily from which of Weber's legitimacy types?

Question 3 of 5

Which characteristic most clearly distinguishes a coup d'etat from a revolution?

Question 4 of 5

Russia under Vladimir Putin is most accurately classified as an example of which political phenomenon?

Question 5 of 5

Based on the descriptions above, which of the following best characterizes the difference between Country A and Country B?