Challenges from
Political & Social Cleavages
Explore how ethnic, religious, regional, and class divisions create fault lines in political systems and challenge state legitimacy and stability.
What Is a Political Cleavage?
A cleavage is a deep and persistent division in society that translates into political conflict. These divisions are not temporary disagreements: they are rooted in identity, geography, economics, or culture and shape how people vote, organize, and relate to the state.
Major Types of Social Cleavages
Why Cleavages Matter for Governance
Cross-cutting vs. Reinforcing Cleavages
Cleavage vs. Political Issue
| Cleavage | Political Issue | |
|---|---|---|
| Duration | Deep, persistent, generational | Can be temporary or shifting |
| Basis | Identity: ethnicity, religion, class | Policy: taxes, trade, environment |
| Mobilization | Shapes party systems, movements | May shift between elections |
| Example | Sunni-Shia divide in Iran | Debate over fuel subsidies |
| Resolution | Requires structural accommodation | Can be resolved by policy change |
How States Manage Cleavages
Suppression vs. Accommodation
How to Analyze Cleavages on the AP Exam
Case Study: Nigeria
Case Study: Iran
Case Study: China & Russia
| China | Russia | |
|---|---|---|
| Key cleavage | Han vs. ethnic minorities (Uyghurs, Tibetans) | Center (Moscow) vs. periphery (Chechnya, ethnic republics) |
| State response | Suppression: assimilation, surveillance, detention | Co-optation + force: installing loyal leaders, military action |
| Political expression | Separatist sentiments, international condemnation | Chechen wars, regional strongmen (Kadyrov) |
| Legitimacy impact | Weakened internationally, internal control maintained | Fragile stability dependent on strongman rule |
Case Study: Mexico & United Kingdom
Cleavages Shape Party Systems
Common Mistakes on the AP Exam
AP6 Country Cleavage Summary
| Country | Primary Cleavage | Management |
|---|---|---|
| China | Han vs. ethnic minorities | Suppression, assimilation |
| Iran | Shia theocracy vs. minorities/secularists | Suppression, Guardian Council vetting |
| Mexico | Class inequality, indigenous marginalization | Social programs, limited accommodation |
| Nigeria | Ethnic + religious + regional | Federalism, zoning, federal character |
| Russia | Center vs. periphery (Chechnya) | Co-optation + military force |
| UK | National/regional + class | Devolution, democratic institutions |
Question 1 of 5
Which of the following best illustrates a reinforcing cleavage?
Question 2 of 5
Nigeria's federal character principle is best described as an example of which cleavage management strategy?
Question 3 of 5
How does Iran's Guardian Council relate to the management of political and social cleavages?
Question 4 of 5
Which of the following is a key difference between how China and the United Kingdom manage their internal cleavages?
Question 5 of 5
Political analyst: "In Country X, the same ethnic group that is religiously distinct also lives in the poorest region and has historically been excluded from political power. Over the last decade, this group has formed its own political party, which now demands either greater autonomy or outright secession."
Based on the passage, which concept from comparative politics best explains the dynamics described?