01 / 21

Challenges from
Political & Social Cleavages

Explore how ethnic, religious, regional, and class divisions create fault lines in political systems and challenge state legitimacy and stability.

AP Comparative Government

What Is a Political Cleavage?

A cleavage is a deep and persistent division in society that translates into political conflict. These divisions are not temporary disagreements: they are rooted in identity, geography, economics, or culture and shape how people vote, organize, and relate to the state.

Major Types of Social Cleavages

Ethnic / Racial
Divisions based on ethnicity, race, or tribal identity: e.g., Yoruba vs. Igbo vs. Hausa in Nigeria
Religious
Conflicts between faith traditions: e.g., Sunni vs. Shia in Iran, secular vs. religious in Mexico
Regional
Urban vs. rural, center vs. periphery: e.g., Northern vs. Southern Nigeria, coastal vs. interior China
Class / Economic
Rich vs. poor, landowners vs. workers: e.g., oligarchs vs. masses in Russia, income inequality in Mexico

Why Cleavages Matter for Governance

STATE Legitimacy supports Social Cleavages challenge Policy Demands pressure Instability risks

Cross-cutting vs. Reinforcing Cleavages

Cross-cutting Ethnic Group A Class Interest overlap Identities cross: reduces intensity of any one divide Reinforcing Ethnic + Religious + Regional Identities stack: deepens divisions and conflict risk

Cleavage vs. Political Issue

Cleavage Political Issue
Duration Deep, persistent, generational Can be temporary or shifting
Basis Identity: ethnicity, religion, class Policy: taxes, trade, environment
Mobilization Shapes party systems, movements May shift between elections
Example Sunni-Shia divide in Iran Debate over fuel subsidies
Resolution Requires structural accommodation Can be resolved by policy change

How States Manage Cleavages

Federalism
Divides power between central and regional governments to give ethnic/regional groups autonomy: e.g., Nigeria's 36 states
Consociationalism
Power-sharing among major groups with guaranteed representation: e.g., Nigeria's zoning principle for the presidency
Co-optation
Authoritarian regimes absorb opposition leaders into the system to defuse dissent: e.g., China's united front work

Suppression vs. Accommodation

Suppression Censorship Forced assimilation Banning opposition parties Detention of minorities Short-term stability, long-term resentment vs. Accommodation Federalism / devolution Proportional representation Affirmative action Language / cultural rights Sustainable stability, but complex governance

How to Analyze Cleavages on the AP Exam

1
Identify the cleavage. Name the specific division: ethnic, religious, regional, or class-based.
2
Explain its political expression. How does the cleavage manifest? Parties, protests, separatism, voting patterns?
3
Evaluate the state response. Is the government using accommodation, co-optation, or suppression?
4
Assess the outcome. Does the response strengthen or weaken legitimacy and stability?
5
Compare across countries. Draw a parallel to another AP6 country for the comparative question.

Case Study: Nigeria

North: Hausa-Fulani Muslim majority, agrarian SW: Yoruba Mixed faith SE: Igbo Christian Reinforcing cleavages: Ethnicity + Religion + Region + Class Response: Federalism, zoning, federal character principle

Case Study: Iran

Religious Cleavage
Shia theocratic state marginalizes Sunni minorities (Kurds, Baloch), secular reformists, and religious dissenters
Ethnic Cleavage
Persians dominate; Azeris, Kurds, Arabs, and Baloch face cultural and linguistic suppression

Case Study: China & Russia

China Russia
Key cleavage Han vs. ethnic minorities (Uyghurs, Tibetans) Center (Moscow) vs. periphery (Chechnya, ethnic republics)
State response Suppression: assimilation, surveillance, detention Co-optation + force: installing loyal leaders, military action
Political expression Separatist sentiments, international condemnation Chechen wars, regional strongmen (Kadyrov)
Legitimacy impact Weakened internationally, internal control maintained Fragile stability dependent on strongman rule

Case Study: Mexico & United Kingdom

Mexico
Class cleavage: extreme income inequality between elites and indigenous/rural poor. Regional: wealthy north vs. poorer south. Response: social programs (e.g., AMLO's cash transfers), but structural inequality persists.
United Kingdom
Regional/national cleavage: England vs. Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland. Class: working-class North vs. affluent Southeast. Response: devolution (Scottish Parliament, Welsh Senedd), but Brexit reignited tensions.

Cleavages Shape Party Systems

Cleavage (e.g., ethnic) mobilizes Party A Represents Group 1 Party B Represents Group 2 Party C Represents Group 3 Multi-party Competition or coalition politics

Common Mistakes on the AP Exam

✕ Confusing cleavage with issue
A cleavage is a deep, identity-based division (Sunni vs. Shia). A policy debate over oil revenue distribution is an issue, not a cleavage itself.
✕ Assuming all cleavages cause conflict
Cross-cutting cleavages can actually reduce conflict. Not every divided society collapses: management strategy matters.
✕ Treating countries as monolithic
Saying "Nigeria is divided" is too vague. Specify which groups, which cleavage type, and which region for full credit.

AP6 Country Cleavage Summary

Country Primary Cleavage Management
China Han vs. ethnic minorities Suppression, assimilation
Iran Shia theocracy vs. minorities/secularists Suppression, Guardian Council vetting
Mexico Class inequality, indigenous marginalization Social programs, limited accommodation
Nigeria Ethnic + religious + regional Federalism, zoning, federal character
Russia Center vs. periphery (Chechnya) Co-optation + military force
UK National/regional + class Devolution, democratic institutions

Question 1 of 5

Which of the following best illustrates a reinforcing cleavage?

Question 2 of 5

Nigeria's federal character principle is best described as an example of which cleavage management strategy?

Question 3 of 5

How does Iran's Guardian Council relate to the management of political and social cleavages?

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following is a key difference between how China and the United Kingdom manage their internal cleavages?

Question 5 of 5

Based on the passage, which concept from comparative politics best explains the dynamics described?