Thermodynamic &
Kinetic Control
Discover why reactions can yield different products depending on temperature and time: the battle between speed and stability.
Two Products, One Reaction
Many reactions can form more than one product. The product that forms depends on the reaction conditions. Two key categories emerge:
The Energy Landscape
Why Does This Matter?
In organic synthesis and industrial chemistry, choosing the wrong conditions can yield the wrong product entirely. Understanding control lets chemists:
Core Principle: \( E_a \) vs. \( \Delta G \)
The Role of Temperature
Reversibility and Reaction Time
The distinction between kinetic and thermodynamic control also depends on whether the reaction is reversible:
Freeze a product distribution by slowing exchange
At 400 K, the given product distribution changes from 50% N after 5 minutes to 80% N after 120 minutes. Cooling an aliquot can approximately preserve its distribution if interconversion becomes sufficiently slow.Time and temperature: four observations
At 400 K, the given product distribution changes from 50% N after 5 minutes to 80% N after 120 minutes. Cooling an aliquot can approximately preserve its distribution if interconversion becomes sufficiently slow.A quench slows exchange; it does not stop motion
A 400 K aliquot with a 50:50 M:N distribution may approximately retain that distribution on cooling to 250 K if interconversion slows sufficiently.Kinetic vs. Thermodynamic
| Kinetic Control | Thermodynamic Control | |
|---|---|---|
| Determined by | \( E_a \) (rate) | \( \Delta G \) (stability) |
| Temperature | Low | High |
| Reaction time | Short | Long |
| Reversibility | Irreversible or quenched early | Reversible, at equilibrium |
| Product | Fastest to form | Most stable |
The Boltzmann Connection
The fraction of molecules with enough energy to overcome a barrier \( E_a \) at temperature \( T \) is given by the Boltzmann factor:
At low T, the exponential drops steeply with \( E_a \): even a small difference in activation energy causes a large difference in rate. At high T, both barriers become accessible and the rate difference shrinks, allowing equilibrium to dictate the outcome.
How to Identify the Product
Example 1: HBr + 1,3-Butadiene
Example 2: Enolate Alkylation
Consider a ketone with two possible deprotonation sites. The base and conditions determine which enolate forms:
Example 3: Sulfonation Revisited
Electrophilic aromatic substitution of naphthalene provides another classic illustration:
Quantitative Energy Profile
We can express the product ratio using the Arrhenius equation. For two competing pathways A and B:
Notice that as \( T \to \infty \), the kinetic ratio approaches \( A_A / A_B \approx 1 \), washing out selectivity. Meanwhile, the thermodynamic ratio still favors the more stable product.
What About Catalysts?
Catalysts lower the activation energy but do not change the free energy of products. Their role in selectivity is nuanced:
Common Mistakes
Question 1 of 5
The kinetic product of a reaction is the one that:
Question 2 of 5
In the addition of HBr to 1,3-butadiene, the 1,4-addition product is the:
Question 3 of 5
A catalyst is added to a reaction that was previously under kinetic control. What is the most likely effect on product distribution?
Question 4 of 5
At very high temperatures (\( T \to \infty \)), the Boltzmann factor \( e^{-E_a/RT} \) approaches:
Question 5 of 5
Which combination of conditions would most reliably produce the thermodynamic product in a reversible reaction?