01 / 21

Resonance &
Formal Charge

Master how delocalized electrons create multiple valid Lewis structures and use formal charge to identify the most stable contributor.

AP Chemistry

What Is Resonance?

Some molecules cannot be accurately described by a single Lewis structure. When electrons, especially lone pairs and pi bonds, can be placed in more than one valid arrangement, we draw multiple structures called resonance structures.

Ozone: A Classic Example

Ozone (\( \text{O}_3 \)) has two equivalent resonance structures. Neither alone captures the true electron distribution: each O–O bond is actually a \(1.5\) bond.

O O O ↔ O O O double bond single bond single bond double bond Both O–O bonds = 1.5

Why Does Resonance Matter?

Stability
Delocalized electrons lower energy. More equivalent resonance structures means greater stabilization.
Bond Lengths
Resonance hybrids have intermediate bond lengths: shorter than single, longer than double bonds.
Reactivity
Knowing where electron density concentrates helps predict which sites react with electrophiles or nucleophiles.

The Formal Charge Formula

Formal charge (FC) is a bookkeeping tool that assigns a hypothetical charge to each atom in a Lewis structure, assuming all bonds share electrons equally.

Rules for the Best Resonance Structure

1
Minimize formal charges. The structure with the smallest magnitudes of formal charge on all atoms is most stable.
2
Sum of FCs = overall charge. For a neutral molecule, all formal charges must sum to zero. For an ion, they sum to the ion charge.
3
Negative FC on electronegative atoms. If charges cannot be avoided, place negative FC on more electronegative atoms (O, N, F).
4
Avoid like charges on adjacent atoms. Placing two positive or two negative charges on neighboring atoms is energetically unfavorable.

Resonance vs. Isomers

Resonance Structures Structural Isomers
Atom positions Same Different
Electron arrangement Different Different
Real molecules? No: hybrid is real Yes: each is a distinct compound
Connected by \( \leftrightarrow \) (double-headed arrow) Not interconvertible without bond breaking
Example \( \text{O}_3 \) resonance forms Ethanol vs. dimethyl ether

How to Draw Resonance Structures

1
Draw a valid Lewis structure. Satisfy the octet rule (or duet for H). Count all valence electrons.
2
Identify movable electrons. Look for lone pairs adjacent to a pi bond, or pi bonds that can shift.
3
Push electrons with curved arrows. Move a lone pair into a bond, or shift a pi bond. Keep atoms fixed.
4
Verify each new structure. Check that total electron count is unchanged and no atom exceeds its octet (except period 3+).
5
Calculate formal charges. Use \( \text{FC} = V - L - S \) on every atom. Rank structures by stability.

Example: \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) Formal Charges

N O O O FC = +1 FC = 0 FC = −1 FC = −1 −
\( \text{N: } 5 - 0 - 4 = \)\( +1 \)   |   \( \text{O}_{db}: 6 - 4 - 2 = \)\( 0 \)
\( \text{O}_{sb}: 6 - 6 - 1 = \)\( -1 \)   |   \( \text{Sum: } +1 + 0 - 1 - 1 = \)\( -1 \) ✓

Three Equivalent Resonance Structures of \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \)

N O O O − ↔ N O O O − ↔ N O O O − All three structures are equivalent contributors
Each N–O bond order in the hybrid = \( \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33 \)
The negative charge is delocalized equally over all three oxygens

Example: \( \text{CO}_2 \) Resonance

\( \text{CO}_2 \) has 16 valence electrons. We can draw three possible Lewis structures. Let's calculate formal charges to decide which contributes most.

O C O FC = 0 FC = 0 FC = 0 ★ Best structure ↔ O C O FC = +1 FC = 0 FC = -1 Minor contributor
\(\text{O=C=O}\) dominates because all formal charges = 0
A third mirror-image structure (O−C≡O) also exists as a minor contributor

Example: \( \text{OCN}^{-} \) : Ranking Contributors

The cyanate ion (\( \text{OCN}^{-} \)) has three resonance structures. We rank them by formal charge distribution.

Structure II (Best)
\( [:\ddot{O}-C\equiv N:]^{-} \)
FC: \(\text{O} = -1\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = 0\)
Negative FC on O (most electronegative atom): Excellent
Structure I (Close second)
\( [\ddot{O}=C=\ddot{N}]^{-} \)
FC: \(\text{O} = 0\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = -1\)
Negative FC on N (less electronegative than O): Good
Structure III (Worst)
\( [:\stackrel{+}{O}\equiv C-\ddot{N}:]^{-} \)
FC: \(\text{O} = +1\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = -2\)
Large charges, \(+1\) on O: very unfavorable

Bond Order in the Hybrid

The bond order in a resonance hybrid is the average across all structures. This determines the actual bond strength and length.

\( \text{NO}_3^{-} \)
3 structures, each N–O bond appears as double once and single twice: \( \frac{2+1+1}{3} = \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33 \)
\( \text{CO}_3^{2-} \)
Same pattern as nitrate: each C–O bond order = \( \frac{4}{3} \approx 1.33 \)
\( \text{O}_3 \)
2 structures: each O–O bond appears as double once and single once: \( \frac{1+2}{2} = 1.5 \)

Equivalent vs. Non-equivalent Structures

Equivalent Non-equivalent
Contribution Equal weight Unequal: best structure contributes most
Formal charges Same pattern in each Different patterns
Bond lengths All equivalent bonds are identical Bonds closer to the dominant structure are shorter
Examples \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \), \( \text{CO}_3^{2-} \), benzene \( \text{OCN}^{-} \), \( \text{CO}_2 \)

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Moving Atoms
Resonance structures differ only in electron placement. Never move an atom's position: that creates an isomer, not a resonance form.
✕ Wrong Arrow
Use the double-headed arrow (\( \leftrightarrow \)), not the equilibrium arrow (\( \rightleftharpoons \)). Resonance is not a dynamic equilibrium.
✕ Ignoring Electronegativity
Placing a positive formal charge on the most electronegative atom (e.g., F or O) makes that structure a poor contributor.
✕ Exceeding Octets in Period 2
C, N, O, F have no d orbitals available. Never place more than 8 electrons around these atoms in any resonance structure.
✕ Changing Electron Count
Every resonance structure must have the same total number of valence electrons. Double-check your count after drawing each form.

Summary: Key Takeaways

1
Resonance structures are valid Lewis structures that differ only in electron arrangement (not atom positions).
2
The resonance hybrid is the true representation: a weighted average of all contributors.
3
Formal charge \( = V - L - S \) helps rank structures. Minimize charges; negative on electronegative atoms.
4
More resonance = more delocalization = greater stability (resonance energy).
5
Bond order in the hybrid = average over all structures. Determines actual bond length and strength.

Question 1 of 5

What is the formal charge on nitrogen in a Lewis structure of \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) where N forms one double bond and two single bonds to oxygen?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement about resonance structures is correct?

Question 3 of 5

The \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) ion has three equivalent resonance structures. What is the bond order of each N–O bond in the hybrid?

Question 4 of 5

For \( \text{CO}_2 \), which resonance structure is the dominant contributor?

Question 5 of 5

When ranking non-equivalent resonance structures, a structure is less favorable if it: