Resonance &
Formal Charge
Master how delocalized electrons create multiple valid Lewis structures and use formal charge to identify the most stable contributor.
What Is Resonance?
Some molecules cannot be accurately described by a single Lewis structure. When electrons, especially lone pairs and pi bonds, can be placed in more than one valid arrangement, we draw multiple structures called resonance structures.
Ozone: A Classic Example
Ozone (\( \text{O}_3 \)) has two equivalent resonance structures. Neither alone captures the true electron distribution: each O–O bond is actually a \(1.5\) bond.
Why Does Resonance Matter?
The Formal Charge Formula
Formal charge (FC) is a bookkeeping tool that assigns a hypothetical charge to each atom in a Lewis structure, assuming all bonds share electrons equally.
Rules for the Best Resonance Structure
Resonance vs. Isomers
| Resonance Structures | Structural Isomers | |
|---|---|---|
| Atom positions | Same | Different |
| Electron arrangement | Different | Different |
| Real molecules? | No: hybrid is real | Yes: each is a distinct compound |
| Connected by | \( \leftrightarrow \) (double-headed arrow) | Not interconvertible without bond breaking |
| Example | \( \text{O}_3 \) resonance forms | Ethanol vs. dimethyl ether |
How to Draw Resonance Structures
Example: \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) Formal Charges
Three Equivalent Resonance Structures of \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \)
Example: \( \text{CO}_2 \) Resonance
\( \text{CO}_2 \) has 16 valence electrons. We can draw three possible Lewis structures. Let's calculate formal charges to decide which contributes most.
Example: \( \text{OCN}^{-} \) : Ranking Contributors
The cyanate ion (\( \text{OCN}^{-} \)) has three resonance structures. We rank them by formal charge distribution.
FC: \(\text{O} = -1\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = 0\)
Negative FC on O (most electronegative atom): Excellent
FC: \(\text{O} = 0\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = -1\)
Negative FC on N (less electronegative than O): Good
FC: \(\text{O} = +1\), \(\text{C} = 0\), \(\text{N} = -2\)
Large charges, \(+1\) on O: very unfavorable
Bond Order in the Hybrid
The bond order in a resonance hybrid is the average across all structures. This determines the actual bond strength and length.
Equivalent vs. Non-equivalent Structures
| Equivalent | Non-equivalent | |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution | Equal weight | Unequal: best structure contributes most |
| Formal charges | Same pattern in each | Different patterns |
| Bond lengths | All equivalent bonds are identical | Bonds closer to the dominant structure are shorter |
| Examples | \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \), \( \text{CO}_3^{2-} \), benzene | \( \text{OCN}^{-} \), \( \text{CO}_2 \) |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Summary: Key Takeaways
Question 1 of 5
What is the formal charge on nitrogen in a Lewis structure of \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) where N forms one double bond and two single bonds to oxygen?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement about resonance structures is correct?
Question 3 of 5
The \( \text{NO}_3^{-} \) ion has three equivalent resonance structures. What is the bond order of each N–O bond in the hybrid?
Question 4 of 5
For \( \text{CO}_2 \), which resonance structure is the dominant contributor?
Question 5 of 5
When ranking non-equivalent resonance structures, a structure is less favorable if it: