Adult ESL/ELL Intermediate • Interpretive Communication (Listening & Reading)

Identifying Writer's Opinion — I can identify a writer's opinion or recommendation in a short text at my level.

Learn to distinguish what a writer believes from what a writer simply reports as fact.

Intermediate English illustration with speaking, writing, and listening symbols
Inside this lesson 10 sections 5 questions 5 figures

SECTION 1

Historical Context & Motivation

The ability to recognize a writer's opinion is one of the most useful skills in critical reading. People have always needed to evaluate written arguments — in newspapers, books, or online posts. As English became a global language, it became more and more important for language learners to tell the difference between a personal viewpoint and a reported fact. Misreading an opinion as a fact — or a fact as an opinion — can lead to real misunderstandings in school, at work, and in daily life.

1900s • Rise of Mass Media

Newspapers and magazines began mixing news reports with opinion pieces. Readers needed to tell the difference between a reporter sharing facts and a writer sharing personal views. This became an important part of basic reading education.

1960s • Communicative Language Teaching

Language teachers moved away from grammar drills and started using real-world texts in class. Finding a writer's viewpoint in everyday reading became a core part of learning English as a second language.

1990s • Teaching Critical Reading

Teachers began asking students to think more carefully about texts: Who wrote this? Why did they write it? What point of view does it show? These questions are central to identifying opinion in any text.

2010s • Digital Age & Misinformation

The internet filled the world with blogs, social media posts, and product reviews. Telling opinions apart from facts became more important than ever. ESL and ELL programs began placing greater focus on reading online texts carefully and thinking about them critically.

Today, intermediate English learners see opinions everywhere — in product reviews, news articles, essays, and work emails. The main question this lesson answers is simple but very useful: How can you tell what a writer personally believes or recommends, even when the language is new or indirect?

SECTION 2

Core Principles & Definitions

Before you can identify a writer's opinion, you need to understand the difference between two types of statements. A fact is a statement that can be checked — you can look it up, measure it, or prove it is true or false. An opinion is a statement that shows what someone personally thinks or feels. Opinions cannot be proven true or false because they reflect the writer's own view. A recommendation is a special type of opinion where the writer tells the reader what they should do. Learning to tell these apart is the main goal of this lesson.

1

Fact vs. Opinion

A fact can be checked and proven (e.g., "Water boils at 100°C"). An opinion expresses a belief or feeling (e.g., "Hot tea is the best drink"). Always ask: Can this be proven?
2

Signal Words & Phrases

Writers often use specific words to signal their opinion: "I think," "in my view," "should," "the best," "unfortunately." These phrases are clues that a personal judgment is coming.
3

Evaluative Language

Describing words that judge quality — such as "excellent," "terrible," "surprisingly," "obviously" — show that the writer is giving an evaluation, not just reporting information.
4

Recommendations

When a writer uses words like "should," "must," "ought to," or phrases like "I recommend" and "it would be better to," they are making a recommendation — a special form of opinion that tells the reader what to do.
5

Context & Purpose

Knowing the text type (review, news story, blog post) and the writer's purpose (to persuade, inform, or entertain) helps you predict where opinions will appear — often in the conclusion or at the start of a paragraph.
✦

KEY TAKEAWAY

Think of reading a text like listening to a friend describe a restaurant. When your friend says, "The restaurant is on Main Street" — that is a fact you can check on a map. But when your friend says, "The pasta was amazing, and you should definitely go" — that is an opinion plus a recommendation. In writing, the same difference exists: signal words, evaluative adjectives, and words like "should" are the clues that your friend's tone of voice would normally give you.

SECTION 3

Visual Explanation — Fact vs. Opinion Spectrum

Not every statement is purely factual or purely opinion-based. Many sentences in real-world texts fall somewhere in between. The diagram below shows how statements move from checkable facts on the left, through mixed statements in the middle, to strong personal opinions and recommendations on the right. Paying attention to the language clues in each zone will help you classify what you read.

FACT ← → OPINION SPECTRUMPURE FACTMIXEDSTRONG OPINIONFACT ZONE• Verifiable data / statistics• Dates, names, measurements• "According to research…"Ex: "The class has 25 students."MIXED ZONE• Facts + evaluative words• "Many people believe…"• Soft words: "seems," "may"Ex: "The large class is noisy."OPINION ZONE• "I think / I believe…"• "should / must / best"• Strong adjectives & adverbsEx: "The class should be smaller."SIGNAL WORD EXAMPLESOPINION SIGNALSI think / I believe / In my opinionshould / must / ought tothe best / the worst / amazingunfortunately / obviouslyFACT SIGNALSAccording to / Research showsIn 2024 / The data indicatesStudies confirm / It is locatedwas founded / consists of
The spectrum above shows how language shifts from checkable facts (blue, left) through mixed statements (violet, center) to strong opinions and recommendations (pink, right). Notice how signal words in each zone change — factual texts use data and sources, while opinion texts use evaluative adjectives, words like "should," and personal phrases.

As you can see in the diagram, the left side of the spectrum contains language that reports checkable information — dates, numbers, and references to research. The right side contains language that reveals what the writer personally thinks or recommends. The middle zone is especially important for intermediate readers because many real-world texts mix facts and opinions in the same paragraph, or even in the same sentence. Learning to notice when the language shifts from one zone to another is the key skill you will practice throughout this lesson.

SECTION 4

How It Works — A Step-by-Step Reading Strategy

Identifying a writer's opinion in a text is not a matter of luck — it is a step-by-step process. The strategy below is called the SCAP Method (Scan, Classify, Analyze, Paraphrase). You can use it with any short text. Each step builds on the one before, helping you move from a first reading to a clear understanding of what the writer believes or recommends.

THE SCAP METHODSSCANRead the text quickly.Note the text type.CCLASSIFYUnderline signal words.Mark F (fact) or O (opinion).AANALYZEAsk: What does thewriter believe / want?PPARAPHRASEState the opinion inyour own words.EXAMPLE TEXT"The new campus library opened on September 3. It has three floors andover 50,000 books. However, I think the study rooms are too small, andthe university should add more quiet areas for students."S → Text type: short review / commentC → Signals: "I think", "too small", "should"A → Writer believes rooms are small; wants more quiet areasP → "The writer thinks the study rooms need to be biggerand recommends adding more quiet spaces."
The SCAP Method provides a four-step process: Scan the text for context, Classify each sentence as fact or opinion, Analyze the writer's underlying belief, and Paraphrase the opinion in your own words.

The SCAP Method works because it breaks a reading task into smaller, easier steps. The first step, scanning, helps you understand the text type and general topic before you focus on details. The second step, classifying, trains you to spot the language clues — signal words, evaluative adjectives, and words like "should" — that separate opinion from fact. The third step, analyzing, helps you understand what the writer truly believes or wants. Finally, the fourth step, paraphrasing, lets you confirm your understanding by putting the opinion into your own words. If you cannot restate the opinion in your own words, go back to an earlier step and try again.

SECTION 5

Detailed Breakdown — Signal Words & Phrases by Category

Signal words are the most reliable clues for identifying opinion. They work like road signs on a highway: they tell you what kind of content is coming next. This section groups the most important signal words and phrases into five categories. Learning even a few from each group will greatly improve your ability to find opinions in any short text.

CategorySignal Words & PhrasesExample Sentence
Personal BeliefI think, I believe, in my opinion, in my view, from my perspective, it seems to meI think online classes are more convenient than in-person lectures.
Recommendationshould, must, ought to, I recommend, it would be better to, I suggestStudents should study vocabulary every day to improve quickly.
Evaluation / Judgmentthe best, the worst, excellent, terrible, important, wonderful, disappointingThis is the best textbook for intermediate learners.
Emotional Toneunfortunately, surprisingly, thankfully, luckily, sadly, clearly, obviouslyUnfortunately, the school cafeteria closes too early.
Softening Wordsit seems, it appears, perhaps, might, may, possibly, could beIt seems that group projects may not be effective for all students.

Five categories of opinion signal words with examples from academic and everyday contexts

⚠

WATCH OUT

Not every sentence with "should" is an opinion. Sometimes "should" describes what is expected to happen — for example, "The package should arrive by Friday" is more of a prediction than a personal recommendation. Always look at the context: if the writer is telling the reader to take action, "should" signals an opinion. If the writer is describing an expected outcome, it is closer to a factual prediction.

The fifth category — softening words — deserves special attention because these words can hide a strong opinion. When a writer says "it seems that" or "perhaps," they may be sharing a genuine opinion but using polite or careful language to soften it. Do not assume that soft language means the writer has no opinion. A softened opinion is still an opinion.

SECTION 6

Worked Example — Reading a Product Review

Let us apply the SCAP Method to a realistic text you might encounter in daily life: an online product review. Read the text carefully, then follow each step.

📝

SAMPLE TEXT — PRODUCT REVIEW

"I bought the QuietMax noise-canceling headphones last month. They cost $89 and come with a carrying case. The sound quality is excellent, and the battery lasts about 20 hours. However, I think the headband is uncomfortable for people with large heads. Overall, the QuietMax is a great choice, but I would recommend trying them on in a store before you buy."

Applying the SCAP Method

  1. 1

    Step 1 — Scan

    Read the entire text quickly. Identify the text type: this is a product review. The topic is noise-canceling headphones. Product reviews usually contain both factual descriptions and personal evaluations, so you should expect to find both facts and opinions.
    Text type identified: product review → opinions expected
  2. 2

    Step 2 — Classify Each Sentence

    Go through each sentence and mark it as fact (F) or opinion (O). Sentence 1 ("I bought… last month") is F — verifiable purchase. Sentence 2 ("They cost $89…") is F — verifiable price and feature. Sentence 3 ("The sound quality is excellent…") begins as O ("excellent" is evaluative) and continues with F ("battery lasts about 20 hours" is measurable). Sentence 4 ("I think the headband is uncomfortable…") is O — "I think" and "uncomfortable" are clear opinion signals. Sentence 5 ("the QuietMax is a great choice") is O — "great choice" is evaluative. Sentence 6 ("I would recommend trying them on…") is O — this is a direct recommendation.
    Facts: sentences 1, 2 | Opinions: sentences 3 (partially), 4, 5, 6
  3. 3

    Step 3 — Analyze the Writer's Belief

    Now ask: what does the writer believe overall? The writer has a mostly positive opinion of the headphones — they use words like "excellent" and "great choice." However, the writer also expresses a negative opinion about the comfort of the headband. The recommendation ("try them on in a store") connects directly to the comfort concern.
    Writer's belief: positive overall, with a specific concern about comfort
  4. 4

    Step 4 — Paraphrase the Opinion

    Express the writer's opinion in your own words without copying the original text. This confirms your understanding and is a useful exercise for building vocabulary and writing fluency.
    "The writer thinks the QuietMax headphones have very good sound and battery life, but the headband may be uncomfortable for some people. The writer suggests testing the headphones in a store before purchasing."

SECTION 7

Where Opinions Appear — Common Text Types Compared

Different types of texts contain different amounts of fact and opinion. Understanding where opinions are likely to appear in each text type gives you an advantage as a reader. A newspaper opinion column, for example, is almost entirely opinion, while a news report is expected to be mostly factual. The table below summarizes the most common text types you will encounter as an intermediate English learner and shows where to look for the writer's opinion in each one.

Text TypeExpected Opinion LevelWhere to Find the Opinion
Product ReviewHigh — writer evaluates a productThroughout, especially in the conclusion and star rating
Opinion ColumnVery High — the entire purpose is to persuadeIn the main argument (often paragraph 1) and the conclusion
News ArticleLow — aims to report facts objectivelyIn quoted statements from sources; word choice may subtly reveal bias
Blog PostMedium to High — varies by authorIn personal stories, recommendations, and the overall tone
Academic EssayMedium — supported by evidenceIn the thesis statement, topic sentences, and the conclusion
Workplace EmailLow to Medium — often uses polite, careful languageIn suggestions ("I think we should…") and closing recommendations

Comparison of common text types by opinion density and location

✦

KEY TAKEAWAY

Imagine you are looking for something buried in the ground. You would not dig in a random place — you would first study the area to know where to look. Similarly, knowing the text type tells you where to look for the writer's opinion. In opinion columns, the opinion is right on the surface. In news articles, you may need to look more carefully — at quoted sources and specific word choices — to notice any bias.

SECTION 8

Connection to Advanced Reading — Implicit Opinion & Author Bias

So far, we have focused on explicit opinions — opinions the writer states directly using clear signal words. However, as you advance in your English reading ability, you will encounter implicit opinions, where the writer's viewpoint is not stated directly. Instead, it is hidden in word choice, which facts the writer includes or leaves out, the order of information, or even the use of quotation marks. Finding implicit opinions is a more advanced skill, but knowing they exist prepares you for more challenging reading in the future.

FeatureExplicit Opinion (This Lesson)Implicit Opinion (Advanced)
How expressedDirectly stated with signal words like "I think" or "should"Hidden in word choice, selected facts, tone, or structure
Difficulty levelIntermediate — signal words provide clear markersAdvanced — requires inference and careful analysis
Example"I believe public transport is better than driving.""While cars sit idle in traffic, the city's new buses glide past." (No stated opinion, but word choice favors buses.)
Reader strategyLook for signal words → classify → paraphraseThink about word choice, missing perspectives, and how the text is organized
Common text typesReviews, opinion columns, blog posts, emailsNews articles, textbooks, advertisements, political speeches

Comparison of explicit opinion identification (this lesson) with implicit opinion detection (advanced skill)

As you continue to develop your English reading skills, you will gradually move from identifying clearly stated opinions to noticing more subtle forms of bias and persuasion. The foundation you build in this lesson — recognizing signal words, classifying statements, and paraphrasing the writer's stance — is the same foundation that supports those more advanced skills. Think of explicit opinion identification as the ground floor of a building; finding hidden opinions is the upper floor, and you cannot reach it without first mastering the basics.

SECTION 9

Practice Problems

Question 1: CONCEPTUAL

What is the difference between a fact and an opinion? In your own words, explain how you would tell these two types of statements apart, and provide one original example of each.
Show answer
A fact is a statement that can be checked and proven true or false — for example, "The library opens at 8 a.m." You can verify this by looking at the library's schedule. An opinion, on the other hand, is a statement that reflects a personal belief or judgment and cannot be proven — for example, "The library is the best place to study." The key difference is: can you check it? If you can measure it, count it, or confirm it with evidence, it is a fact. If it depends on personal feelings, taste, or values, it is an opinion.

Question 2: BASIC

Read the following sentence and identify whether it is a fact, an opinion, or a recommendation. Then explain which signal word(s) helped you decide: "Students should join a study group because it helps them learn faster."
Show answer
This sentence is a recommendation. The word "should" is the main signal word — it tells the reader to take a specific action. The clause "because it helps them learn faster" gives the writer's reason, but the idea that study groups help students learn "faster" is itself a personal judgment, not a proven fact. The overall sentence tells the reader what to do, which makes it a recommendation — a specific type of opinion.

Question 3: INTERMEDIATE

Read the following short text and identify all the opinions. List the signal words that helped you find them. "The Riverside Café opened in 2019. It serves breakfast and lunch every day. The pancakes are delicious, and the coffee is reasonably priced at $3.50. Unfortunately, the service is slow during weekends. I would recommend visiting on a weekday for the best experience."
Show answer
There are three opinions in this text. First, "The pancakes are delicious" is an opinion because "delicious" is an evaluative adjective expressing a personal taste judgment. Second, "Unfortunately, the service is slow during weekends" is an opinion because "unfortunately" is an emotional tone word revealing the writer's negative feeling, and "slow" is a personal evaluation. Third, "I would recommend visiting on a weekday for the best experience" is a recommendation, signaled by "I would recommend" and the superlative "best." The remaining sentences — the opening date (2019), the menu description (breakfast and lunch), and the coffee price ($3.50) — are checkable facts.

Question 4: APPLIED

You receive the following email from a coworker. Use the SCAP Method to identify the writer's opinion and recommendation. Write your paraphrase. "Hi everyone, the company is offering two training options this quarter: a communication skills workshop (March 10) and a data analysis course (March 17). Both are free. I took the communication workshop last year, and it was extremely useful. I think we should all sign up for that one. The data course might be helpful too, but the communication skills will benefit our team the most."
Show answer
Applying the SCAP Method: (S) This is a workplace email about training options — emails often contain opinions expressed as suggestions. (C) Signal words include "extremely useful" (evaluative adjective), "I think" (personal belief), "should all sign up" (recommendation with "should"), "might" (softening word), and "the most" (superlative judgment). Facts include the dates, course names, and the cost (free). (A) The writer believes the communication workshop is more valuable than the data course and wants the team to choose it. (P) Paraphrase: "The writer strongly recommends the communication skills workshop because they found it very helpful when they attended last year. They believe it will be more beneficial for the team than the data analysis course."

Question 5: CRITICAL THINKING

Consider the following two sentences about the same topic: Sentence A: "The city government spent $2 million to build a new park." Sentence B: "The city government wasted $2 million on an unnecessary park." Both sentences report the same basic event. Explain how Sentence B reveals the writer's opinion even though the writer does not use "I think" or "I believe." What specific word choices transform a factual statement into an opinion? What does this teach you about identifying opinions when signal words are missing?
Show answer
Sentence B contains no traditional signal words like "I think" or "should," yet it clearly expresses the writer's negative opinion. The word "wasted" replaces the neutral verb "spent" — "wasted" implies the money was used poorly, which is a judgment, not a fact. Similarly, "unnecessary" is an evaluative adjective that expresses the writer's belief that the park was not needed. These two word choices transform an objective report into a statement of opinion. This example teaches an important lesson: opinions do not always use obvious signal words. Sometimes the writer's viewpoint is expressed through their choice of words. As you become a stronger reader, pay attention not only to clear opinion markers but also to whether words carry positive, negative, or neutral meanings — because word choice is one of the most common ways writers share their views without saying "I think" or "I believe."

SUMMARY

Lesson Summary

Summary

In this lesson, you learned how to identify a writer's opinion or recommendation in a short text. The foundation of this skill is understanding the difference between a fact (a statement you can check and verify) and an opinion (a personal belief or judgment). You explored five categories of signal words — personal belief phrases, recommendation words, evaluative adjectives, emotional tone adverbs, and softening words — that act as reliable clues for finding opinions in any text.

You practiced the SCAP Method (Scan, Classify, Analyze, Paraphrase), a step-by-step reading strategy that turns opinion identification from a guess into a clear process. You also learned that different text types — reviews, opinion columns, news articles, emails — contain different amounts of opinion, and knowing the text type helps you predict where opinions are most likely to appear. Finally, you were introduced to the concept of implicit opinion, which prepares you for more advanced critical reading as your English proficiency grows.

Varsity Tutors • Adult ESL/ELL Intermediate • Identifying Writer's Opinion