01 / 21

Identifying Sources
of Error

Learn to spot systematic and random errors in experimental data, understand how they affect results, and evaluate what could go wrong in a scientific study.

ACT Science

What Is Experimental Error?

Every scientific experiment contains some degree of error: the difference between the measured value and the true value. On the ACT Science section, you will be asked to identify what went wrong in an experiment and how it affects the data.

Two Major Types of Error

Systematic Error
Consistent, repeatable bias that shifts all measurements in the same direction. Results are precise but not accurate.
Random Error
Unpredictable fluctuations that cause measurements to scatter around the true value. Results may be accurate on average but not precise.

Accuracy vs Precision

Accurate + Precise Accurate, Not Precise Precise, Not Accurate Bullseye = true value Dots = measured values

Sources of Systematic Error

1
Instrument calibration: A scale that always reads \(0.5\text{ g}\) too high will shift every measurement upward by the same amount.
2
Flawed procedure: Measuring the temperature of a liquid without stirring creates a consistently biased reading from one region of the container.
3
Environmental factors: A draft near an analytical balance causes all mass readings to be slightly lower than the true mass.
4
Observer bias: Consistently reading a meniscus from the wrong angle (parallax error) biases all volume readings.

Sources of Random Error

1
Measurement limitations: Reading a ruler to the nearest mm introduces small, unpredictable variation in each reading.
2
Environmental fluctuations: Room temperature changes slightly between trials, causing small variations in reaction time measurements.
3
Human reaction time: Starting and stopping a stopwatch introduces unpredictable variation in each timing measurement.
4
Sample variability: Individual organisms or materials differ slightly, causing natural scatter in biological and chemical experiments.

Systematic vs Random: The Key Test

Systematic Error Random Error
Direction Always the same direction Both directions unpredictably
Affects Accuracy Precision
Fixed by repeating? No: repeating gives same bias Yes: averaging reduces scatter
Fixed by Recalibrating / redesigning More trials / better instruments
ACT clue words "always too high," "consistently" "varied," "fluctuated," "scattered"

The Error Identification Framework

1. Read the Data 2. Compare to Expected 3. One Direction or Scattered? Systematic Error Random Error Recalibrate / Redesign More Trials / Average

How to Apply on the ACT

1
Identify the expected result. What should the experiment have produced if everything worked perfectly?
2
Spot the discrepancy. Are measured values consistently too high or too low, or scattered unpredictably?
3
Trace the cause. Look for equipment issues, procedural flaws, environmental conditions, or human factors mentioned in the passage.
4
Evaluate the fix. Would recalibration solve it (systematic), or would repeating trials help (random)?
5
Eliminate wrong answers. Choices that blame unrelated variables or confuse error types are common distractors.

Example 1: The Biased Scale

A student measures the mass of a sample five times. The true mass is \(25.0\text{ g}\). The recorded values are: \(25.8\), \(25.7\), \(25.9\), \(25.8\), \(25.7\text{ g}\).

24.5 25.0 25.5 26.0 26.5 True: 25.0
\(+0.8\text{ g}\) bias

Example 2: Scattered Timing Data

A student uses a stopwatch to time a ball rolling down a ramp. The expected time is \(3.2\text{ s}\). Results: \(2.8\), \(3.5\), \(3.0\), \(3.6\), \(2.9\text{ s}\).

2.5 s 3.0 s 3.5 s 4.0 s Expected: 3.2 s Wide scatter around true value

Example 3: Both Errors at Once

A chemistry student measures the boiling point of water. The accepted value is \(100.0^\circ\text{C}\). Their thermometer was not zeroed correctly. Results: \(102.3\), \(101.5\), \(103.1\), \(101.8\), \(102.7^\circ\text{C}\).

99 100 101 102 103 True: 100.0
Systematic bias \(+2^\circ\text{C}\)
+ random scatter \(\pm 0.8^\circ\text{C}\)

Confounding Variables vs Error

The ACT sometimes asks about confounding variables: uncontrolled factors that provide an alternative explanation for the results. These are different from measurement error.

Confounding Variable
An uncontrolled factor that varies alongside the independent variable, making it impossible to determine which caused the effect.
Source of Error
A flaw in measurement or procedure that causes data to deviate from the true value, but does not change the relationship being tested.

Quantifying Error: Percent Error

When the ACT gives you a known/accepted value, you can quantify how far off the measured result is using percent error:

From Example 1: the average measured mass was \(25.78\text{ g}\), and the accepted value was \(25.0\text{ g}\).

A high percent error strongly suggests systematic error: something is consistently pushing the result away from the accepted value.

Common Mistakes on Error Questions

✕ Confusing Accuracy and Precision
Saying "the data is accurate" when the values are tightly grouped but far from the true value. That is precise, not accurate.
✕ Thinking More Trials Fix Everything
Repeating trials averages out random error but does nothing for systematic error. A miscalibrated tool stays miscalibrated.
✕ Blaming Unrelated Variables
Choosing an answer that mentions a variable unrelated to the measurement in question. Always trace the error to the specific step described.

Summary: Error at a Glance

Concept Definition ACT Signal
Systematic Error Consistent one-direction bias "always too high/low"
Random Error Unpredictable scatter "varied," "inconsistent"
Accuracy Closeness to true value Low percent error
Precision Closeness of repeated trials Tight clustering of data
Confounding Variable Uncontrolled co-varying factor "could also explain"
Percent Error \(\frac{|\text{M} - \text{A}|}{|\text{A}|} \times 100\%\) Quantifies accuracy

Question 1 of 5

A student measures the density of a metal block five times. The true density is \(8.90\text{ g/cm}^3\). Results: \(9.42, 9.45, 9.41, 9.44, 9.43\text{ g/cm}^3\). What type of error is most likely present?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following would most effectively reduce random error in an experiment timing how long a pendulum takes to complete \(10\) swings?

Question 3 of 5

A group of students measures the volume of a liquid using a graduated cylinder. Student A consistently reads the meniscus from above, while Student B reads it at eye level. Student A's readings are all slightly higher than Student B's. Student A's readings contain:

Question 4 of 5

An experiment tests whether fertilizer increases plant growth. Group A receives fertilizer; Group B does not. However, Group A is placed near a window receiving more sunlight. The extra sunlight is best described as:

Question 5 of 5

A student calculates a percent error of \(0.04\%\) for their measured boiling point of water. Their five trials produced values of \(99.7, 100.3, 99.8, 100.5, 99.9^\circ\text{C}\). Which statement best describes this data?