Experimental
Design
Master the principles of controlled experiments, learn to identify variables, and build the skills to analyze scientific studies on the ACT.
What Is Experimental Design?
Experimental design is the blueprint for a scientific investigation. It determines how data are collected, which factors are manipulated, and how results are interpreted. On the ACT Science section, roughly 6 out of 40 questions test your ability to evaluate the design of an experiment.
The Three Types of Variables
How Variables Connect
The independent variable flows through the experiment (with controlled conditions held constant) and produces changes in the dependent variable.
The Role of the Control Group
A control group receives no treatment (or a placebo). It serves as a baseline for comparison: without it, you cannot determine whether the independent variable actually caused the observed change.
Core Principle: One Variable at a Time
Correlation vs. Causation
Sample Size and Replication
Larger sample sizes reduce the effect of random variation and produce more reliable results. Replication: repeating the experiment to verify results are consistent.
Analyzing an Experiment: Step by Step
Worked Example: Plant Growth
Worked Example: Enzyme Activity
Independent: temperature. Dependent: reaction rate. The enzyme works fastest at \(37^{\circ}\text{C}\) (body temperature) and slows dramatically at higher temperatures due to denaturation.
Worked Example: Confounding Variables
Common Mistakes on the ACT
Bias and Validity
Summary Comparison Table
| Controlled Experiment | Observational Study | |
|---|---|---|
| Manipulation | Researcher changes the IV | Researcher observes naturally |
| Control Group | Yes, required | No, not always present |
| Random Assignment | Yes, subjects assigned randomly | No, groups occur naturally |
| Can Establish Causation? | Yes | No, only correlation |
| Example | Drug trial with placebo group | Survey linking diet and health |
Question 1 of 5
A scientist tests the effect of fertilizer concentration on plant growth by growing 5 groups of plants with different fertilizer amounts. All plants receive the same amount of sunlight, water, and soil. What is the independent variable?
Question 2 of 5
In an experiment testing whether a new drug reduces blood pressure, Group A receives the drug and Group B receives a sugar pill. Group B is best described as the:
Question 3 of 5
A study finds that people who exercise more tend to have lower resting heart rates. The researchers surveyed 500 adults but did not assign anyone to exercise programs. Which conclusion is best supported?
Question 4 of 5
A student tests whether music affects memorization. Group 1 studies in silence, Group 2 studies with classical music, and Group 3 studies with rock music. However, Group 3 also studies in a different room with brighter lighting. What is the primary flaw?
Question 5 of 5
Which of the following changes would most improve the reliability of an experiment that tested only 5 subjects per group?