01 / 21

Evaluating Models
& Explanations

Learn to assess scientific models, judge whether data supports a hypothesis, and identify strengths and weaknesses in competing explanations.

ACT Science

What Is a Scientific Model?

A scientific model is a simplified representation of a natural phenomenon. It can be a diagram, equation, verbal description, or conceptual framework that helps scientists predict and explain observations.

Descriptive
Explains how something works: diagrams of cell division, maps of ocean currents
Predictive
Forecasts what will happen next: climate models, population growth curves
Quantitative
Uses math to express relationships: \( F = ma \), \( PV = nRT \)

Models vs. Explanations

A model shows the structure or pattern. An explanation tells you why that pattern exists by linking evidence to a mechanism or cause. The ACT Science section frequently presents competing explanations for the same data.

Why This Matters on the ACT

The ACT Science section includes Conflicting Viewpoints passages (about 15-20% of the test) that present two or more hypotheses. You must:

1
Identify what each model or explanation claims
2
Compare how the models differ in their predictions
3
Evaluate which model is best supported by the data
4
Predict what new evidence would strengthen or weaken each model

The Evaluation Cycle

Observation Model / Hypothesis Prediction Test / Experiment Evaluate fit with data

What Makes a Model Strong?

1
Consistency with data: The model explains all current observations without contradiction
2
Predictive power: The model accurately predicts outcomes of new experiments
3
Explanatory scope: The model accounts for a wide range of phenomena, not just one case
4
Simplicity: Among equally supported models, the simpler one is preferred (parsimony)

Supported vs. Proven

A critical distinction on the ACT: scientific models are supported or weakened by evidence. They are never absolutely "proven" or "disproven" by a single experiment.

Supported Weakened
Meaning Data is consistent with the model's predictions Data contradicts the model's predictions
Certainty Increases confidence, never reaches 100% Reduces confidence, may prompt revision
ACT language "consistent with," "would agree," "supports" "inconsistent with," "would challenge," "weakens"

How to Evaluate: Step by Step

1
Identify each model's claim: What does each scientist/hypothesis say is happening and why?
2
Find the key difference: What specific prediction or mechanism separates the two models?
3
Check the data: Does the evidence match Model A's prediction, Model B's, both, or neither?
4
Watch for scope: Can one model explain more observations than the other?
5
Answer the question: Match the question stem to strengthen, weaken, compare, or predict

Worked Example: Dinosaur Extinction

Two scientists propose explanations for the mass extinction 66 million years ago.

Scientist 1
An asteroid impact ejected debris into the atmosphere, blocking sunlight and collapsing food chains over months.
Scientist 2
Massive volcanic eruptions (Deccan Traps) released toxic gases over thousands of years, gradually destabilizing ecosystems.

Evaluating the Evidence

Time (millions of years ago) 68 66.5 66 64 Iridium spike Deccan Traps activity Species diversity Sharp drop at 66 Mya

Example 2: Competing Heat Models

A beaker of water is heated. Two students propose different explanations for why the temperature plateaus at \(100^\circ\text{C}\).

Student A
Energy is used to break intermolecular bonds (phase change), so temperature stays constant during boiling.
Student B
The thermometer has reached its maximum reading and can't measure higher temperatures.

Testing with New Evidence

We test by heating ethanol (boiling point \(78^\circ\text{C}\)) with the same thermometer.

Temp (°C) Time 0 25 50 78 100 Water Ethanol

Strengthen vs. Weaken Questions

On the ACT, you'll be asked: "Which finding would most weaken Scientist 1's hypothesis?" Here's how to reason through it:

1
Restate the claim: What exactly does the model predict?
2
Find the opposite: What observation would directly contradict that prediction?
3
Check each answer: Which choice describes that contradicting observation?

ACT Question Types

Identify
"According to Scientist 1, what causes X?" Locate the claim in the passage.
Compare
"On which point do the scientists disagree?" Find where predictions diverge.
Evaluate
"Which finding would weaken Scientist 2?" Match evidence to predictions.
Predict
"If Scientist 1 is correct, what would happen to Y?" Extend the model's logic.

Common Mistakes

✕ Confusing Models
Mixing up which scientist said what. Always re-read the specific model before answering.
✕ Absolute Language
Choosing "proves" or "disproves" instead of "supports" or "weakens." Science uses tentative language.
✕ Irrelevant Evidence
Picking data that sounds impressive but doesn't actually relate to the model's specific prediction.

Summary: Evaluation Checklist

Question Asks Strategy Look For
What does Scientist X claim? Re-read that model's section Direct quotes or paraphrases
Where do they disagree? Compare key predictions Opposite predictions about same variable
What would strengthen? Match prediction to evidence Data consistent with the model
What would weaken? Find the contradiction Data that the model cannot explain
What would both agree on? Find common ground Shared assumptions or data

Question 1 of 5

Which finding would most weaken Scientist 1's explanation?

Question 2 of 5

A scientific model is considered strong when it:

Question 3 of 5

Researchers find that ocean pH has decreased uniformly across all major ocean basins, not just near volcanic vents. This finding:

Question 4 of 5

On the ACT, which of the following answer choices should you be most suspicious of?

Question 5 of 5

An experiment shows that birds with magnets are disoriented on cloudy nights but navigate correctly on clear nights. This result: