01 / 21

Drawing Conclusions &
Evaluating Claims

Master the art of interpreting data, identifying supported conclusions, and spotting claims that go beyond the evidence.

ACT Science

What Does Drawing Conclusions Mean?

On the ACT Science section, you will read passages that present experiments, data tables, and graphs. Drawing conclusions means using that evidence to determine what is true, what is likely true, and what cannot be determined from the information provided.

What Is a Claim?

Claim
A statement that something is true, often made by a scientist or student in a passage.
Evidence
The data, observations, or experimental results presented in the passage.
Reasoning
The logical connection that explains why the evidence supports (or refutes) the claim.

The Evidence Funnel

Raw Data & Observations Tables, graphs, descriptions Patterns & Trends Valid Conclusion Broad: many data points Focused: clear trends Narrow: specific claim

Think of drawing a conclusion like a funnel: you start with a wide pool of data, narrow it down to observable patterns, and then arrive at a specific, evidence-based statement.

The Core Rule of Evidence-Based Reasoning

Supported "As temperature increased, solubility decreased." (Graph on next slide shows this) Unsupported "Solubility will continue to decrease above 80°C." (Extrapolation beyond data range) vs.

Supported vs. Unsupported Conclusions

Temperature (\(^{\circ}\text{C}\))
Solubility (\(\text{g/L}\))
0 20 40 60 80 Supported by data ✓ Extrapolation ✕

Correlation vs. Causation

Correlation Causation
Definition Two variables change together One variable causes the other to change
Evidence needed A pattern or trend in data A controlled experiment isolating variables
Example Ice cream sales and drownings both rise in summer Adding fertilizer causes plant height to increase
ACT trap Often stated as if it proves causation Requires showing no confounding variables

Types of ACT Science Questions

Data Interpretation
"According to the graph, which substance had the highest solubility at \(60^\circ\text{C}\)?"
Drawing Conclusions
"Based on the results, which conclusion is best supported?"
Evaluating Claims
"Does the data support Scientist 1's claim that..."

The 5-Step Method

1
Read the question first. Identify what it is asking: a trend, a comparison, or a claim evaluation.
2
Locate the relevant data. Find the specific table, graph, or paragraph the question references.
3
Identify the pattern. Is the relationship increasing, decreasing, constant, or nonexistent?
4
Match to the answer. Choose the option that directly restates or logically follows from the data pattern.
5
Eliminate overstatements. Cross out answers that use "always," "proves," or extend beyond the data range.

Example 1: Reading a Table

Trial Fertilizer (\(\text{g}\)) Plant Height (\(\text{cm}\))
1012
2518
31025
41531
52030

Example 2: Graph Interpretation

Time (min) pH Level 0 5 10 15 20 25 2 4 6 8 10 Solution A Solution B

Example 3: Conflicting Viewpoints

Scientist 1
"The increase in \(\text{CO}_2\) levels, a greenhouse gas, is the primary cause of rising global atmospheric temperatures, which in turn heats the oceans."
Scientist 2
"Natural oceanic cycles are the primary driver of temperature changes; the effect of \(\text{CO}_2\) is minor in comparison."

Signal Words to Watch For

Safe Words
"suggests," "is consistent with," "is associated with," "supports the hypothesis that"
Danger Words
"proves," "always," "never," "the only cause," "guarantees," "will definitely"

Strengthening vs. Weakening a Claim

The Claim Strengthens New data is consistent with the prediction Adds support, not proof Weakens New data contradicts the prediction Challenges, not disproves

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Confusing Correlation with Causation
Just because two variables change together does not mean one caused the other. Look for controlled experiments before claiming causation.
✕ Extrapolating Beyond the Data
If data covers \(0^\circ\text{C}\) to \(80^\circ\text{C}\), you cannot draw conclusions about \(100^\circ\text{C}\). Stay within the tested range.
✕ Using Outside Knowledge
The ACT tests whether you can read the passage, not whether you know the topic. Only use information provided in the passage.

Summary Checklist

Question Type What to Do Key Trap to Avoid
Best supported conclusion Find answer that restates the data trend Overgeneralization
Evaluate a claim Match claim to specific data points Choosing "sounds right" over evidence
Strengthen / weaken Ask: does new info agree or disagree? Reversing strengthen vs. weaken
Conflicting viewpoints Identify the exact point of disagreement Confusing what scientists agree on vs. disagree on
Cannot be determined Look for data gaps or untested variables Assuming data covers everything

Question 1 of 5

Which conclusion is best supported by the data?

Question 2 of 5

On which point do both scientists agree?

Question 3 of 5

Which statement about this study is most accurate?

Question 4 of 5

Which conclusion is best supported by comparing both experiments?

Question 5 of 5

Does the data support the researcher's claim?