Comparing Viewpoints
& Hypotheses
Learn to identify, compare, and evaluate competing scientific explanations: the key skill for ACT Science's Conflicting Viewpoints passage.
What Is a Viewpoint?
On the ACT Science section, a viewpoint is a scientist's or student's explanation for a natural phenomenon. Each viewpoint presents a claim supported by evidence and reasoning. The Conflicting Viewpoints passage gives you two or more viewpoints that disagree on the same question.
Anatomy of a Conflicting Viewpoints Passage
Key Terms You Must Know
The Core Principle of Comparison
Viewpoint vs. Hypothesis
| Viewpoint | Hypothesis | |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Broad explanation or model | Specific, testable prediction |
| Example | "Dinosaur extinction was caused by an asteroid" | "If an asteroid hit, then iridium levels should spike at the boundary layer" |
| Testability | May be too broad to test directly | Designed to be confirmed or refuted |
| ACT format | Labeled "Scientist 1," "Student 2," etc. | Often embedded within a viewpoint |
Types of Comparison Questions
The 5-Step Comparison Strategy
Worked Example: Dinosaur Extinction
Finding the Fork in the Example
Agreement: Both scientists agree that dinosaurs went extinct approximately 66 million years ago and that environmental disruption played a role.
Disagreement: They disagree on the cause (asteroid vs. volcanism) and the speed (sudden vs. gradual).
Worked Example 2: Ocean Acidification
Evaluating New Evidence
Suppose researchers discover that ocean pH is dropping uniformly across all oceans, including remote areas far from agriculture.
Three Viewpoints at Once
Some ACT passages present three scientists. The strategy is the same: identify each claim, then map agreements and disagreements pairwise.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Summary Comparison
| Agreement Questions | Disagreement Questions | New Evidence Questions | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What to find | Shared facts or assumptions | The exact point of divergence | Which prediction the data matches |
| Strategy | Look for overlap in claims | Find the "fork" sentence | Test each viewpoint's prediction against the data |
| Common trap | Picking a point only one mentions | Choosing a superficial difference | Using outside knowledge |
Question 1 of 5
Scientist 1: The primary cause of coral bleaching is rising ocean temperatures due to global warming. When water temperatures exceed a coral's thermal tolerance, the coral expels its symbiotic algae (zooxanthellae), turning white and losing its energy source.
Scientist 2: While temperature plays a role, the primary cause of coral bleaching is increased ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Ozone depletion has allowed more UV light to penetrate shallow waters, directly damaging zooxanthellae and triggering expulsion.
On which point do both scientists agree?
Question 2 of 5
Student A: The mass of an object determines how quickly it falls. Heavier objects fall faster because gravity pulls more strongly on them.
Student B: In a vacuum, all objects fall at the same rate regardless of mass. Air resistance, not mass, causes differences in falling speed in everyday conditions.
Which experiment would best resolve the disagreement?
Question 3 of 5
Scientist 1 claims that volcanic eruptions caused Earth's last ice age by blocking sunlight. Scientist 2 claims that changes in Earth's orbit (Milankovitch cycles) reduced solar input. New data show that ice core records reveal a gradual cooling over 10,000 years with no volcanic ash layers during the cooling period. This evidence:
Question 4 of 5
Scientist 1: Birds evolved from small, feathered theropod dinosaurs. Fossil evidence shows a gradual transition from dinosaur scales to feathers, with intermediary species like Archaeopteryx.
Scientist 2: Birds evolved from small, tree-dwelling reptiles (not dinosaurs) that developed gliding membranes that later became wings. The similarities to theropods are due to convergent evolution, not direct ancestry.
Which discovery would most weaken Scientist 1's viewpoint?
Question 5 of 5
Hypothesis X: A newly discovered species of deep-sea fish produces bioluminescence primarily to attract prey. The light draws smaller organisms toward the fish.
Hypothesis Y: The bioluminescence primarily serves as camouflage (counter-illumination). By matching the faint light from above, the fish avoids detection by predators looking up from below.
Researchers observe that the fish only produces light on its underside and adjusts brightness to match ambient light from above. This observation: