01 / 20

Comparing Viewpoints
& Hypotheses

Learn to identify, compare, and evaluate competing scientific explanations: the key skill for ACT Science's Conflicting Viewpoints passage.

ACT Science

What Is a Viewpoint?

On the ACT Science section, a viewpoint is a scientist's or student's explanation for a natural phenomenon. Each viewpoint presents a claim supported by evidence and reasoning. The Conflicting Viewpoints passage gives you two or more viewpoints that disagree on the same question.

Anatomy of a Conflicting Viewpoints Passage

Background Information Central Question / Phenomenon Scientist 1 Claim + Evidence + Reasoning (explains phenomenon one way) Scientist 2 Claim + Evidence + Reasoning (explains it a different way) Compare & Contrast

Key Terms You Must Know

Claim
The main assertion a scientist makes about a phenomenon
Evidence
Data, observations, or experimental results cited to support the claim
Reasoning
The logical connection explaining why the evidence supports the claim

The Core Principle of Comparison

Viewpoint A Unique claims Unique evidence Unique reasoning Viewpoint B Unique claims Unique evidence Unique reasoning Shared Accepted facts Common data Point of Disagreement = What the ACT tests

Viewpoint vs. Hypothesis

Viewpoint Hypothesis
Scope Broad explanation or model Specific, testable prediction
Example "Dinosaur extinction was caused by an asteroid" "If an asteroid hit, then iridium levels should spike at the boundary layer"
Testability May be too broad to test directly Designed to be confirmed or refuted
ACT format Labeled "Scientist 1," "Student 2," etc. Often embedded within a viewpoint

Types of Comparison Questions

Agreement
"Both scientists would agree that..."
Disagreement
"The scientists disagree about whether..."
Strengthen / Weaken
"Which finding would weaken Scientist 2's view?"
New Information
"If this new data were found, which scientist's view would it support?"

The 5-Step Comparison Strategy

1
Read the introduction first. Identify the central question both viewpoints address.
2
Summarize each viewpoint in one sentence. Capture the core claim, not every detail.
3
Underline key evidence. Mark the specific facts or data each scientist cites.
4
Find the fork. Pinpoint the exact sentence where the two views diverge.
5
Answer from the passage. Every correct answer is directly supported by the text: never infer beyond what is stated.

Worked Example: Dinosaur Extinction

Scientist 1 Asteroid Impact Theory Claim: A massive asteroid caused a sudden mass extinction event. Evidence: Iridium layer at K-Pg boundary, Chicxulub crater, shocked quartz Reasoning: Impact debris blocked sunlight, collapsing the food chain rapidly. Scientist 2 Volcanic Activity Theory Claim: Massive volcanic eruptions caused a gradual extinction over millennia. Evidence: Deccan Traps eruptions, gradual species decline before K-Pg Reasoning: Volcanic gases caused climate change and ocean acidification.

Finding the Fork in the Example

Agreement: Both scientists agree that dinosaurs went extinct approximately 66 million years ago and that environmental disruption played a role.

Disagreement: They disagree on the cause (asteroid vs. volcanism) and the speed (sudden vs. gradual).

Worked Example 2: Ocean Acidification

Student 1
Rising \( \text{CO}_2 \) is the primary driver of ocean acidification. As atmospheric \( \text{CO}_2 \) dissolves in seawater, it forms carbonic acid, lowering pH.
Student 2
Nutrient runoff from agriculture is the primary driver. Algal blooms from excess nitrogen consume oxygen and release acids as they decompose.

Evaluating New Evidence

Suppose researchers discover that ocean pH is dropping uniformly across all oceans, including remote areas far from agriculture.

1
Identify the prediction: Student 2 predicts acidification should be concentrated near coastal agricultural areas.
2
Compare to the data: The new finding shows uniform global pH decline, contradicting Student 2's prediction.
3
Draw the conclusion: This evidence strengthens Student 1 (global \( \text{CO}_2 \) is everywhere) and weakens Student 2 (runoff is localized).

Three Viewpoints at Once

Some ACT passages present three scientists. The strategy is the same: identify each claim, then map agreements and disagreements pairwise.

Scientist 1 Scientist 2 Scientist 3 Agree on X Disagree on Y Disagree on Z

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Confusing the viewpoints
Mixing up which scientist said what. Always re-read the specific passage section before answering.
✕ Adding outside knowledge
Using what you know about the topic instead of what the passage states. ACT answers come only from the text.
✕ Assuming total disagreement
Thinking the scientists disagree on everything. They usually share common ground: find it.

Summary Comparison

Agreement Questions Disagreement Questions New Evidence Questions
What to find Shared facts or assumptions The exact point of divergence Which prediction the data matches
Strategy Look for overlap in claims Find the "fork" sentence Test each viewpoint's prediction against the data
Common trap Picking a point only one mentions Choosing a superficial difference Using outside knowledge

Question 1 of 5

On which point do both scientists agree?

Question 2 of 5

Which experiment would best resolve the disagreement?

Question 3 of 5

Scientist 1 claims that volcanic eruptions caused Earth's last ice age by blocking sunlight. Scientist 2 claims that changes in Earth's orbit (Milankovitch cycles) reduced solar input. New data show that ice core records reveal a gradual cooling over 10,000 years with no volcanic ash layers during the cooling period. This evidence:

Question 4 of 5

Which discovery would most weaken Scientist 1's viewpoint?

Question 5 of 5

Researchers observe that the fish only produces light on its underside and adjusts brightness to match ambient light from above. This observation: