Mastering
Commas
The ACT English section tests comma usage more than any other punctuation rule. Learn the six essential patterns to eliminate errors with confidence.
Why Commas Matter on the ACT
Comma questions appear on nearly every ACT English passage. They account for roughly 10-15% of the entire English section. The good news: comma rules are predictable and learnable.
The Core Principle
Every comma must have a grammatical reason to exist. If you cannot name the rule that justifies a comma, it probably does not belong. On the ACT, "when in doubt, leave it out" is a powerful strategy.
The Six Essential Comma Rules
Rule 1: Lists and Series
When three or more items appear in a series, separate them with commas. The ACT accepts the Oxford comma (the comma before "and") and often tests whether you can spot a missing or misplaced comma in a list.
Rule 2: Introductory Elements
Place a comma after an introductory word, phrase, or clause that comes before the main subject and verb. This signals to the reader where the introduction ends and the main sentence begins.
Rule 3: Nonessential Information
Information that can be removed without changing the core meaning of the sentence must be set off with a pair of commas. Think of the commas as parentheses: the sentence should still make sense without the enclosed phrase.
Rule 4: Compound Sentences
When two independent clauses (each could stand alone as a sentence) are joined by a FANBOYS conjunction, place a comma before the conjunction.
Rule 5: Coordinate Adjectives
Place a comma between two adjectives that independently modify the same noun. Use two tests to decide if adjectives are coordinate:
Test: "bright and elegant dress" → sounds natural → comma needed
Test: "German small car" → sounds wrong → no comma
Rule 6: Never Separate Core Pairs
A comma should never appear between a subject and its verb, or between a verb and its direct object/complement. These are the core pairs of a sentence: splitting them is always wrong.
✓ The experienced teacher explained the concept clearly.
Essential vs. Nonessential
This is the highest-difficulty comma distinction on the ACT. Essential (restrictive) information identifies the noun: removing it changes the meaning. Nonessential information merely adds extra detail.
| Essential (No Commas) | Nonessential (Commas) | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Identifies which one | Adds extra detail |
| Signal word | "that" | "which" / "who" |
| Remove it? | Meaning changes | Meaning stays the same |
| Example | The car that I bought is red. | My car, which is red, needs gas. |
How to Apply on Test Day
Example 1: Introductory Clause
Analysis: "Because the museum was closed for renovations" is a dependent introductory clause. It comes before the main clause "visitors had to wait." Apply Rule 2: place a comma after the introductory clause.
Example 2: Nonessential Phrase
Analysis: "Who is a leading expert in marine biology" provides extra information about Dr. Ramirez. Remove it: "Dr. Elena Ramirez published her findings last week." The sentence still works perfectly. Apply Rule 3: set off with a pair of commas.
Example 3: Compound Sentence Trap
Analysis: This looks like Rule 4 (comma + FANBOYS). But check: what comes after "and"? "Received a standing ovation" has no subject: it is not an independent clause. It is a compound predicate (one subject, two verbs). No comma needed.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Summary of All Six Rules
| Rule | When to Use | Quick Test |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Lists | 3+ items in a series | Count the items |
| 2. Introductory | Before the main clause | Find the subject |
| 3. Nonessential | Extra, removable info | Delete test |
| 4. Compound | Two independent clauses + FANBOYS | Does clause 2 have a subject? |
| 5. Coord. Adj. | Two adjectives modifying same noun | "And" test / swap test |
| 6. No Comma | Never split subject-verb or verb-object | Find the core pairs |
Question 1 of 5
The hiking trail, which had been closed for months due to severe flooding [?] was finally reopened to the public last Saturday. Which version correctly punctuates the bracketed portion?
Question 2 of 5
The underlined portion is: "The new policy requires employees to submit timesheets, and complete a daily log." What is the best choice?
Question 3 of 5
Which option correctly punctuates the following sentence?
Sentence: Although she had never traveled outside the country [?] Priya felt surprisingly calm as the plane took off for Tokyo.
Question 4 of 5
Choose the correctly punctuated version:
Question 5 of 5
What is the best punctuation for the underlined portion?
Sentence: The committee reviewed the proposal [UNDERLINED] they voted unanimously to approve it.