01 / 20

Pose Questions &
Elaborate on Topic

Learn how to ask specific, thoughtful questions and respond with elaboration and detail that moves a discussion forward.

6th Grade Reading

What Does It Mean to Elaborate?

When you elaborate, you go beyond a simple "yes" or "no." You add details, examples, and reasoning that help your listener understand your thinking more deeply.

What Makes a Question Specific?

A specific question targets a particular detail, idea, or moment in a text or discussion. It invites a focused, meaningful response rather than a vague one.

Vague
"What did you think of the story?"
Specific
"Why did the character decide to leave home in Chapter 3?"

Why This Skill Matters

Richer Discussion Ask Questions Elaborate Deeper Understanding Build on Others

Good questions and elaboration create a cycle: your question sparks someone's thinking, their detailed response inspires your next question, and the whole group reaches deeper understanding.

The Core Rule of Discussion

Pose Questions Elaborate in Detail Move Forward

The Question-Elaboration Cycle

Specific Question Detailed Response New Insight Follow-up Question

Great discussions are a cycle, not a straight line. Each specific question leads to an elaborated response, which reveals new insights, which spark even better follow-up questions.

Asking vs. Elaborating

Asking a Question Elaborating a Response
Purpose Invites others to share or clarify Deepens your own point with detail
Sounds like "Why did the author...?" "Can you explain...?" "For example..." "This connects to..."
Effect on group Opens a new thread of thinking Builds on an existing thread
Key skill Being specific and focused Using evidence and examples

How to Pose Specific Questions

1
Anchor to the text. Reference a specific page, paragraph, quote, or event: "On page 12, the narrator says..."
2
Use question stems. Try "Why did...?", "How does...?", "What evidence supports...?", or "What would happen if...?"
3
Target one idea. Avoid multi-part questions. Focus on a single character choice, theme, or claim at a time.
4
Invite elaboration. End with phrases like "...and why do you think so?" or "...can you give an example?"

How to Elaborate Effectively

1
State your point clearly. Begin with a direct claim: "I think the character changed because..."
2
Support with evidence. Cite a quote, scene, or fact: "In the text it says..."
3
Explain your reasoning. Connect the evidence to your point: "This shows that..."
4
Connect to the bigger picture. Tie back to the theme, other texts, or real life: "This reminds me of..."

Example: Weak vs. Strong Question

Weak Question
"Was the book good?"
Strong Question
"How does the author use the storm in Chapter 5 to show the main character's fear of change?"

Example: Weak vs. Strong Elaboration

Weak Response
"I agree. The character was scared."
Strong Elaboration
"I agree that the character was scared, and the text shows this when she hides under the table during the storm. This connects to the theme of overcoming fear because later she steps outside for the first time."

Example: A Full Discussion Exchange

Q
Student A: "Why does Jonas choose to leave the community even though it's dangerous?" (specific question)
E
Student B: "I think Jonas leaves because he learns the truth about 'release.' In Chapter 19, he watches the video and realizes the community is hiding something terrible. He can't stay once he knows." (elaboration with evidence)
F
Student A: "That makes sense. But do you think Jonas also leaves for Gabriel's sake, not just his own? On page 165, he says he can't let Gabriel be released." (follow-up with new evidence)

Sentence Starters That Help

For Questions
"What evidence supports...?"
"Why do you think the author...?"
"Can you explain what you mean by...?"
"How does this connect to...?"
For Elaboration
"For example, in the text..."
"This is important because..."
"I think this connects to..."
"Building on what [name] said..."
For Follow-ups
"I'd like to add to that..."
"That's interesting, but what about...?"
"I agree, and another example is..."
"I see it differently because..."

Common Mistakes to Avoid

✕ Too Vague
Asking "What happened?" instead of targeting a specific event, character, or idea from the text.
✕ No Evidence
Saying "I think so too" without citing a quote, scene, or reason from the text to back up your point.
✕ Off-Topic
Introducing a brand-new topic instead of building on what the group is already discussing.

Your Discussion Checklist

Skill What to Do Check Yourself
Pose Questions Anchor to text, use stems, target one idea Does my question point to something specific?
Elaborate Claim + evidence + reasoning Did I explain why with a text detail?
Contribute Build on others, connect ideas Does my comment move us forward?
Follow Up Ask about what someone else said Am I listening and responding, not just waiting?

Question 1 of 5

A classmate says, "I think the main character is brave." Which response best elaborates on this idea?

Question 2 of 5

Which of the following is the most specific discussion question about a novel?

Question 3 of 5

During a discussion about a poem, a student says: "The poem is sad." What is the biggest problem with this comment?

Question 4 of 5

Which sentence starter would best help you build on another student's idea during a discussion?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best describes the difference between Student A's and Student B's contributions?