01 / 20

Reading vs.
Audio/Visual

Learn to compare and contrast the experience of reading a story, drama, or poem with listening to or viewing an audio, video, or live version of the same text.

6th Grade Reading

What Is a Medium?

A medium is the way a story reaches you. The same tale can arrive through different channels: printed words on a page, an actor's voice in a recording, or moving images on a screen. Each medium delivers the story using different tools.

Text
Words on a page or screen that you read at your own pace.
Audio
Spoken words, sound effects, and music that you listen to.
Visual / Video
Moving images, actors, sets, and costumes that you watch.

Why Compare Mediums?

Every medium emphasizes different parts of a story. When you compare them, you notice what each version adds, removes, or changes. This makes you a more thoughtful reader and viewer.

The Reader's Imagination

TEXT reads YOUR MIND creates images, voices, settings ★ UNIQUE Every reader imagines a different version of the story

The Core Principle

SAME STORY READING You imagine: - Characters' faces - Tone of voice - Setting details - Pace / rhythm AUDIO / VISUAL Creator decides: - Actor's appearance - Music / sound - Camera angles - Timing / speed Different mediums highlight different elements of the same story

Tools of Each Medium

Tool Text (Reading) Audio Video / Live
Words / Dialogue ★ Yes ★ Yes ★ Yes
Imagery Descriptive language Sound effects Sets, costumes, CGI
Tone / Mood Word choice, syntax Voice, music Lighting, color
Pacing Reader-controlled Fixed by narrator Fixed by director
Character Description, thoughts Voice acting Actor performance

"See" and "Hear" in Reading

When we talk about what you "see" and "hear" while reading, we mean the mental pictures and sounds your imagination creates from the author's words. This is different from literally seeing and hearing in a video.

Mental "Seeing"
Figurative language, descriptions, and sensory details paint pictures in your mind.
Mental "Hearing"
Dialogue, rhythm, and word sounds create an inner voice as you read.

What Changes Between Mediums

1
Details added: A film might show a character's costume or a room's decor that the text never described.
2
Details removed: A movie may cut inner thoughts or narration that the book includes.
3
Details changed: An audio version might use dramatic music to create tension the text built through word choice alone.
4
Interpretation shifts: A director or narrator makes choices about emphasis that may differ from what the reader imagined.

How to Compare: Step by Step

1
Read first. Notice what you imagine: settings, character voices, emotions, and pacing.
2
Experience the other version. Watch or listen closely. What specific choices did the creator make?
3
Identify similarities. What stayed the same? Which key scenes or lines appear in both?
4
Identify differences. What was added, removed, or changed? How does this affect your understanding?
5
Evaluate the effect. Which version was more powerful for you, and why?

Example 1: A Poem

Reading
You control the pace. You might pause at "and that has made all the difference" and re-read it. You imagine the forest however you like.
Listening
The actor's tone sounds wistful. The guitar adds a melancholy mood. The pace is set for you: no pausing to re-read.

Example 2: Story to Film

TEXT "The apple changed. Just for an instant." You imagine the color shift vs. FILM Screen shifts from grey to red instantly You see the exact shade the director chose Same moment: different experiences

Example 3: Script vs. Performance

Reading the Script
Stage directions say "a dark, cloaked figure appears." You imagine how frightening it looks. Scrooge's terror is conveyed through his dialogue alone.
Watching the Play
Dim lighting, fog machines, and eerie music create real suspense. The actor playing Scrooge physically trembles and backs away. The ghost is ten feet tall on stilts.

The Comparison Framework

ASK YOURSELF... What did I imagine while reading? What did I perceive while watching/listening? What is similar? What is different? How does it change my experience?

Sensory Channels by Medium

Which senses does each medium engage? Reading Sight (words) Mental (imagined) Audio Hear (voice) Hear (music) Mental (imagined) Video Sight (images) Hear (sound) Sight (actors) Hear (music) Real sense Imagined

Common Mistakes

✕ Saying One Is "Better"
The goal is to compare, not judge. Explain how each version creates a different experience, not which is superior.
✕ Only Listing Plot Events
Don't just say "they both tell the same story." Focus on how the story is told differently: tone, pacing, sensory details.
✕ Ignoring What's Lost
Every adaptation removes something. A film may cut inner thoughts. An audiobook may skip illustrations. Always note what's missing.

Summary Comparison

Feature Reading Audio / Visual
Pace You control it Creator controls it
Imagery Built by your imagination Provided directly
Character voice You imagine it Actor performs it
Inner thoughts Often included Usually removed
Music / sound None (you imagine) Added by creator
Re-reading Easy: flip back Harder: rewind needed

Question 1 of 5

When you read a story, what do the terms "see" and "hear" refer to?

Question 2 of 5

What does the film version add that the text version does not have?

Question 3 of 5

A student reads a novel and then watches the movie adaptation. The novel includes long passages describing the main character's inner thoughts. In the movie, these thoughts are not included. What is the effect of this change?

Question 4 of 5

Which of the following is a key advantage of reading a text compared to watching a video version?

Question 5 of 5

How does the audio version change the experience of the poem compared to reading it?